Human Communication Research · 1984 · 71 citations · 24 references
Social SciencesPsychologySocial PsychologyDecision MakingGroup DynamicsGroup ProcessesCollective Decision-makingGroup BehaviorGroup CommunicationGroup Decision-makingOrganizational Decision-makingTeam Decision-makingDecision ProceduresGroup Decision ProcessesGroup Interaction ProcessesIntergroup Decision-makingOptimal Decision MakingOptimal Decision TheorySmall Group Decision MakingTeam Decision Processes
Although communication scholars usually have assumed that social interaction is intrinsic to the process of producing good group decisions, some writers have argued that social interaction actually may harm the quality of group decisions. Consequently, several noninteractive group decision-making procedures have been proposed; among these are the staticized group procedure and the nominal group procedure. While some research suggests the effectiveness of these non-interactive procedures, no research has compared directly the effect of staticized, nominal, and interacting decision procedures on the quality of group decisions reached with respect to complex, multistage tasks. The present study provides such a comparison. Reasoning that the open exchange of information, opinions, and criticism is necessary for optimal decision-making on complex tasks, it was hypothesized that groups employing an interacting procedure would produce better decisions than groups employing either staticized or nominal decision procedures. It was hypothesized further that subjects in the interacting condition would produce belter individual decisions than those in either the staticized or nominal conditions. Both of these hypotheses were confirmed. In addition, there was some evidence of an “assembly-effect bonus” among groups in the interacting condition.
24
Group Dynamics: The Psychology of Small Group Behavior
S. D. Vander Ark · Journal of Music Therapy · 1972 · 1.1K citations
Group Process and Productivity
Elsa L. Ramsden · Physical Therapy · 1973 · 826 citations
Social Sciences, Organization Studies, Organizational Behavior +15