Deaf in America: Voices From a Culture

TLDR

Historically, medical schools have rarely prepared physicians for complex cultural issues such as those faced by deaf individuals, who have long been viewed as a separate and undesirable culture. The authors aim to clarify the cultural uniqueness of the deaf community. Their work, while compassionate, lacks the methodological rigor of traditional cultural anthropology or linguistics, limiting its scholarly impact. The.

Abstract

Historically, medical schools have seldom prepared an emerging physician to deal with problems so fundamental as nutrition, much less such complex political and ethical issues as the subcultures of poverty, minorities, or the "handicapped." Authors Padden and Humphries have undertaken the task of clarifying the cultural "uniqueness" of the deaf. Being deaf was regarded as a separate but very undesirable culture as early as medieval times, when "the position of the deaf was especially difficult because they were thought to be 'possessed by the devil' or, at least, morally deficient. The deaf could not obtain 'the true faith' since in the Holy Scriptures is written fides ex auditu (faith comes from hearing)." ¹ Although Padden and Humphries write with compassion and understanding, their approach is less rigorous than traditional approaches by cultural anthropologists or linguists, and this in some ways detracts from the structured scholarship that such credentials afford. The