Pneumoconiosis and Respiratory Symptoms in Miners at Eight Collieries

J. M. Rogan, J. R. Ashford, P. J. Chapman, D. P. Duffield, JW Fay, S. Rae

BMJ · 1961 · 52 citations · 11 references

Concepts

Abstract

of the National Coal Board has been described elsewhere (Fay, 1957; Fay and Rae, 1959).Briefly the aim is to establish the relationship between environmental conditions in the coal mines, particularly dust, and occupational pulmonary disease and disability, so that safe levels of dust can be established on a scientific basis.The research, which began in 1953, is essentially long- term and prospective.The first step was to select a sample of collieries which, collectively, would embody the full range of environmental conditions encountered in British coal-mines: 24, later 25, collieries were selected.Then it was decided to examine radiologically the population of these collieries, some 35.000 men, regularly every three to four years while at the same time maintaining, by appropriate sampling techniques, a record of the exposure to dust of each man in the population.Thus it would be possible after a number of years to relate the amount and type of dust in the environment with the prevalence and progression of pneumoconiosis.This plan was put into effect.Soon afterwards, however, evidence began to accumulate which threw doubt on the commonly held belief that simple pneumo- coniosis was a disease causing substantial disability (Lavenne and Belayew, 1953;Gilson and Hugh-Jones, 1955;Carpenter et al., 1956).From three sample surveys, two in a single Welsh v2lley and one in a Lancashire town, Carpenter and his colleagues concluded that miners, whether or not they have simple pneumoconiosis, have more respiratory disability than men of the same age who have never worked in the mines.Higgins et al. (1956), commenting on the same Lancashire survey, observed that miners and ex-miners had significantly more " chronic bron- chitis " than men who had never worked as miners.Newell and Browne (1955) surveyed four collieries in Durham and reported that, while simple pneumoconiosis

References

11