Sociological Focus · 1975 · 178 citations · 25 references
Social SciencesMedical EducationEpistemologyMedical AnthropologyMedical SociologyKnowledge ProductionMedical HistoryPractice TheoryProfessional ResponsibilityProfessionalization Of MedicineBureaucratic MonopolyHistory Of Medical ProfessionalizationMedical Professional IdentityMedical ProfessionalismProfessional AuthorityProfessional FormationProfessional Power
Abstract Historical and cross-cultural data call into question the concept of profession as formulated by British and American sociologists. A common underlying theme, however, is the monopolization of esoteric knowledge as a basis for professional authority. Because of the rapid proliferation of knowledge and technology, Daniel Bell has forecast a professionalized society, in which knowledge will be a source of power. This paper projects an alternative hypothesis based on several societal trends, using medicine as the prototypical profession and providing some cross-cultural evidence. These trends include an erosion of the knowledge monopoly as a result of rising levels of public schooling and sophistication and specific patient education, as well as computerization—which changes accessibility patterns—and new divisions of labor, which disseminate practice skills and information more widely. The consequences are decline of trust in professional decisions and diminution of professional power and authority over clients. Ideological challenges to professional status accompany these developments, which coverge to suggest a deprofessionalized future.
25
Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine
JAMA · 1969 · 1.5K citations
Louis H. Orzack, Terence J. Johnson · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 1975 · 1.1K citations
Ernest Greenwood · Social Work · 1957 · 992 citations
Humanities, Sociology, Culture +8
The Doctor, His Patient, and the Illness
The American Journal of the Medical Sciences · 1957 · 758 citations
Medicine, Psychiatry, Psychology +15