Extracting Minerals from Seawater: An Energy Analysis

Ugo Bardi

Sustainability · 2010 · 220 citations · 12 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Recovering minerals from seawater has been proposed to offset the depletion of conventional ores, yet while major ions such as Na, Mg, Ca, and K are commercially extracted, most other metal ions are present at much lower concentrations. The study estimates the feasibility of extracting these lower‑concentration metal ions by evaluating the energy required. The authors conduct an energy analysis to determine the feasibility of seawater metal extraction. The analysis indicates that extracting most seawater metal ions at land‑mine‑scale production is infeasible due to the enormous energy needed—including for uranium—while lithium extraction could be viable if recycling rates increase.

Abstract

The concept of recovering minerals from seawater has been proposed as a way of counteracting the gradual depletion of conventional mineral ores. Seawater contains large amounts of dissolved ions and the four most concentrated metal ones (Na, Mg, Ca, K) are being commercially extracted today. However, all the other metal ions exist at much lower concentrations. This paper reports an estimate of the feasibility of the extraction of these metal ions on the basis of the energy needed. In most cases, the result is that extraction in amounts comparable to the present production from land mines would be impossible because of the very large amount of energy needed. This conclusion holds also for uranium as fuel for the present generation of nuclear fission plants. Nevertheless, in a few cases, mainly lithium, extraction from seawater could provide amounts of metals sufficient for closing the cycle of metal use in the economy, provided that an increased level of recycling can be attained.

References

12