Not Seeing the Wood for the Trees: Implications of Susceptibility Testing

David P. Fourie, Stanley Lifschitz

American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis · 1988 · 13 citations · 29 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract The adherence of the social sciences to the notions of analytical reductionism, linear causality, and neutral objectivity, which characterize a Newtonian epistemology of science, has been widely criticized. Despite these criticisms, hypnosis research still seems to be firmly embedded in Newtonian thinking. Employment of the reified concept of hypnotic susceptibility and of the practice of susceptibility testing are good examples of such thinking. Two recent studies are discussed in order to illustrate this point. In both studies adherence to the ideas of Newtonian science could be seen to lead to questionable research conclusions. In turn, these conclusions reinforce a view of hypnosis in which contextual factors are ignored. Thus, the idea of susceptibility is embedded within a view of reality which is continually reinforced by the practice of susceptibility testing. Some of the implications of this dilemma for an understanding of hypnosis are highlighted.

References

29