Anthropology and Medicine · 1999 · 25 citations · 39 references
ArtsPsychiatryReligionAsian StudiesHindu StudiesHistory Of ReligionsHindu HistoryHinduismIndian StudiesCaste PrivilegeIndian Social History
Abstract Indian intellectuals have been concerned about the complex links between religion, caste and gender, especially in the formation of social science ideas and practices. The mental and behavioural sciences, however, have only been at the fringes of this interest. As a case‐study, and as an initial and tentative attempt in this area, this paper foregrounds the caste and gender basis of ‘Indian’ psychoanalysis. Appeals have been systematically made for an ‘Indian’ psychoanalysis through the pre‐independent days in the works of Girindrasekhar Bose and others and, more recently, in the works of Sudhir Kakar. This literature has influenced cultural perspectives in ‘Indian’ psychiatry. This paper argues that the Indian assimilation of psychoanalysis is underlined by patriarchal and Hinduistic interests. In the fairly recent history of its formation, psychoanalysis facilitated the representation of upper caste Hindu ideas like no other theory or practice. These ideas are still widely prevalent within the modern writings on Indian psychoanalysis. I argue that the ideological (patriarchal and Hinduistic) basis of psychoanalysis compromises what is offered (to Hindu women and women of other castes and religions) in intervention contexts as ‘cure’. The paper emphasizes the contested nature of ‘culture’ in India because of the multiple religious interest groups and the complex intergroup negotiations.
39
Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge.
Mary Hesse, Karl R. Popper · The Philosophical Quarterly · 1965 · 4.2K citations