Political Studies · 2002 · 37 citations · 14 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyPolitical ScienceContemporary PhilosophySocial InequalityTheory Of JusticeEquality TheoryKantian PhilosophyMoral ResponsibilityNormative EthicsVirtue EthicsLuck EgalitarianismLuck Problem
Ronald Dworkin's recently published book, Sovereign Virtue (hereafter SV), appeals to arguments that are popular within, and ideas that are fundamental to, liberal egalitarianism. These arguments and ideas need to be distinguished and unpacked. The purpose of this paper is partly to do this and to cast doubt on the adequacy of various moves made by Dworkin. In addition, and more importantly I argue that the analysis of the ‘equality of what?’ debate reveals a tension at the heart of contemporary liberal egalitarianism between the Kantian aspiration to eliminate luck and the contemporary aspiration to do political philosophy without metaphysics.
14
Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person
Harry G. Frankfurt · The Journal of Philosophy · 1971 · 4.4K citations
Robert Sugden, Amartya Sen · The Economic Journal · 1986 · 4.1K citations
John T. Granrose · Social Theory and Practice · 1975 · 3.3K citations
On the Currency of Egalitarian Justice
G. A. Cohen · Ethics · 1989 · 2.9K citations