Biometric Authentication on iPhone and Android: Usability, Perceptions, and Influences on Adoption

Chandrasekhar Bhagavatula, Blase Ur, Kevin Iacovino, Su Mon Kywe, Lorrie Faith Cranor, Marios Savvides

2015 · 121 citations · 19 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Biometrics have long been promoted as the future of authentication, and recent Android face unlock and iPhone fingerprint unlock are among the first large‑scale consumer deployments. The study examined the usability of these schemes and users’ experiences, attitudes, and adoption decisions. A 10‑participant within‑subjects lab study and a 198‑participant online survey were conducted. Both face unlock and fingerprint unlock were found easy to use in typical scenarios, but face unlock failed in dark rooms; most participants preferred fingerprint unlock over face unlock or a PIN, and fingerprint users perceived it as more secure and convenient, whereas face unlock users had mixed experiences and many stopped using it.

Abstract

While biometrics have long been promoted as the future of authentication, the recent introduction of Android face unlock and iPhone fingerprint unlock are among the first large-scale deployments of biometrics for consumers. In a 10participant, within-subjects lab study and a 198-participant online survey, we investigated the usability of these schemes, along with users’ experiences, attitudes, and adoption decisions. Participants in our lab study found both face unlock and fingerprint unlock easy to use in typical scenarios. The notable exception was that face unlock was completely unusable in a dark room. Most participants preferred fingerprint unlock over face unlock or a PIN. In our survey, most fingerprint unlock users perceived it as more secure and convenient than a PIN. In contrast, face unlock users had mixed experiences, and many had stopped using it. We conclude with design recommendations for biometric authentication on smartphones.

References

19