Long-Term Prognosis of Isolated Partial Medial Collateral Ligament Ruptures

Abstract

We prospectively observed 38 patients with nonopera tively treated isolated partial ruptures of the knee me dial collateral ligament at 3 months, 4 years, and 10 years after the initial trauma using clinical and radio graphic examinations. The initial diagnoses were based on clinical and arthroscopic examinations. Three months after injury, 28 patients (74%) had re gained nearly normal knee function and muscle strength, and 75% of these patients could perform at their preinjury activity level (competitive team sports). Five patients (13%) had increased valgus laxity (grade I) in the injured knee. After 4 years, the patients had a median Lysholm score of 100 (range, 64 to 100). Thir ty-three patients (87%) had normal knee function dur ing strenuous activities. Repeat injuries to the medial collateral ligament occurred in two patients (5%), and another two patients sustained cruciate ligament inju ries during the follow-up period. After 10 years, the Lysholm score (median, 95; range, 73 to 100) was lower compared with the 4-year score (P < 0.03), but the patients still performed on a similarly high activity level. Five patients (13%) had distinct signs of begin ning osteoarthritis (Fairbank's signs) on radiographs, but none had joint space reduction.