The Place of Liberalism

Jordanna Bailkin

Victorian Studies · 2005 · 18 citations · 29 references

Concepts

Abstract

here was liberalism? From the liberal point of view, this is almost certainly the wrong question to ask. As Uday Singh Mehta notes in his provocative study, Liberalism and Empire (1999), the universalist principles of nineteenth-century liberalism promoted a denial of place in liberal political theory, a purposeful neglect of the significance of territory (120). Liberal thinkers embraced the concept of evolution in time, emphasizing that individuals and societies unfolded in historical stages. But if the significance of time in liberal theory was assured, the role of place was suspect. Indeed, the liberal espousal of historical development was matched by an equally powerful insistence on transcending categories of place—region, territory, or nation—as part of the peculiar pointillism or decentralization of power in liberal society. In the nineteenth century, the repudiation of place was politically meaningful because it aided the articulation of a specifically liberal brand of imperialism. The rejection of place allowed Victorian liberals to refuse the territorial claims that typically bolstered anticolonial nationalist movements. Thus, the doctrine of “placelessness” had great utility for the governance of empire. But it has been a remarkably robust doctrine, a sturdy legacy of liberal thought. It continues to function as a crucial element in the neoliberalisms and neocolonialisms W

References

29