The American Naturalist · 2000 · 304 citations · 53 references
Life SciencesBiologyEcologyEvolutionary EcologyPopulation BiologyPopulation EcologyForaging EcologyLife History TheoryLife History Trade-offsNatural SelectionPopulation CyclesPopulation DynamicsBimodal DistributionBody Size ScalingCompetition DynamicsPopulation SizePopulation Size DistributionResource-driven Population DynamicsSize-structured Models
Cannibals and their victims often share common resources and thus potentially compete. Smaller individuals are often competitively superior to larger ones because of size-dependent scaling of foraging and metabolic rates, while larger ones may use cannibalism to counter this competition. We study the interplay between cannibalism and competition using a size-structured population model in which all individuals consume a shared resource but in which larger ones may cannibalize smaller conspecifics. In this model, intercohort competition causes single-cohort cycles when cannibalism is absent. Moderate levels of cannibalism reduce intercohort competition, enabling coexistence of many cohorts. More voracious cannibalism, in combination with competition, produces large-amplitude cycles and a bimodal population size distribution with many small and few giant individuals. These coexisting ``dwarfs'' and ``giants'' have very different life histories, resulting from a reversal in importance of cannibalism and competition. The population structure at time of birth determines whether individuals suffer severe cannibalism, with the few survivors reaching giant sizes, or whether they suffer intense intracohort competition, with all individuals remaining small. These model results agree remarkably well with empirical data on perch population dynamics. We argue that the induction of cannibalistic giants in piscivorous fish is a population-dynamic emergent phenomenon that requires a combination of size-dependent cannibalism and competition.
53
Cannibalism in Natural Populations
Laurel R. Fox · Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics · 1975 · 1K citations
James F. Kitchell, Donald J. Stewart, David Weininger · Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada · 1977 · 863 citations