International Journal of Audiology · 2013 · 45 citations · 21 references
Health ProfessionsAudiologyAssistive Listening DevicesHearing AidsHearing ScienceAudiologic EvaluationHearing ImpairmentHearing LossHearing Protection DevicesSpeech Perception OutcomesEffect SizeEffect Size AnalysisHearing Aid Benefit MeasurementHearing Aid BenefitsHearing Aid EvaluationSelf-reported Hearing HandicapSpeech Auditory Performance EvaluationSpeech-in-noise Deficits
OBJECTIVE: A recent study suggested that placebo effects are a source of bias in non-blinded hearing-aid trials. Given the potential impact of this finding on the interpretation of non-blinded trials and design of future research trials, the objective of the present study was to investigate the reliability of this effect. DESIGN: Using the same procedure as an earlier study, participants were told that they were taking part in a trial of new hearing-aid technology. Participants compared two devices that were acoustically identical, except one was described as "new" and the other as "conventional". Participants completed a speech-in-noise test, sound quality ratings, and rated overall personal preference for both hearing aids. STUDY SAMPLE: Sixteen adult hearing-aid users. RESULTS: Participants had significantly better mean speech-in-noise performance (70.9% versus 66.8%, Z = 2.30, p = 0.02, effect size Pearson's r = 0.15) and sound quality ratings for the "new" hearing aid (8.1 versus 7.4, Z = - 2.99, p = 0.003, r = 0.28). A significant proportion of participants (75%) expressed an overall preference for the "new" hearing aid (p = 0.001, effect size φc = 0.66). CONCLUSION: Placebo effects reliably impact on hearing-aid trials. In order to control for placebo effects, double-blind methodology is optimal. However, when double-blinding is not possible other strategies may be appropriate.
21
Henry K. Beecher · Journal of the American Medical Association · 1955 · 1.8K citations
Parametric measures of effect size.
Robert Rosenthal · 1994 · 1.6K citations
The Handbook of Research Synthesis
The Abbreviated Profile of Hearing Aid Benefit
Robyn M. Cox, Genevieve C. Alexander · Ear and Hearing · 1995 · 1K citations
The Importance of Placebo Effects in Pain Treatment and Research
Judith A. Turner · JAMA · 1994 · 863 citations
Medicine, Pharmacotherapy, Surgery +17