DETECTION OF INFECTIOUS HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY TYPE 1 VIRUS IN DISCARDED SYRINGES OF INTRAVENOUS DRUG USERS

Marta Ortiz Rivera, Óscar García‐Algar, Joan A. Caylà, Oriol Vall Combelles, Alfredo García‐Sáiz

The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal · 1998 · 19 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Casual needle stick injury from a discarded syringe left in a public place by an intravenous drug user (IDU) is a frequent accident that might be a risk for human immunodeficiency type 1 virus contagion.1 The volumes of blood transferred in this situation as well as the amount of virus have been estimated.2 The mere traces of blood on a needle, plus the probable deleterious effect of the environment on the activity of the virus suggest that the risk, if any, should be minimal. The presence and prevalence of HIV-1 markers (antibodies, p24 antigen and proviral DNA) have been demonstrated in syringes coming from IDUs3 and from needle and syringe exchange programs.4,5 Infectious virus in syringes has been detected in needle stick simulations5 and HIV-1 has been cultured from a syringe from a "shooting gallery,"4 but we have found no published data about the presence of infectious virus in discarded syringes and the related transmission risk. Methods and results. We assessed the presence of infectious HIV-1 in 28 syringes discarded in public places and in 10 syringes from a syringe exchange program. Ten syringes experimentally contaminated were included as a control group, 5 with blood from an AIDS patient and 5 with blood from a healthy individual negative for HIV-1 antibodies at the time of the study and 3 months later. All the syringes were attached to a patent needle and had visible blood. Culture methods allow detection of infectious HIV-1 but require at least 28 incubation days. PCR is a rapid assay that detects proviral DNA. We have used a method combining the advantages of culture and PCR following the previously described technique by Ariyoshi et al.6 that permits rapid assessment of infectious virions. Syringes were washed internally by flushing 10 times with 1 ml of phosphate-buffered saline with added penicillin and streptomycin. After centrifugation HIV-1 antibodies were measured by an enzyme-linked immunoassay (Hoechst Iberica S.A.), and a Western blot (Immunogenetics) was made for confirmation, both of them in the supernatant layer of the washing solution. This supernatant was also used for culture. Samples were inoculated in 107 phytohemagglutinin-stimulated lymphocytes. Cultures were incubated at 37°C in 5% CO2 for 48 h. DNA was extracted from these short term cultures, and PCR amplification was performed with the use of two pairs of primers in pool gene.7 Sensitivity was optimized by using nested PCR, which can detect between 1 and 5 copies of HIV-1 proviral DNA. PCR products were analyzed on 2% ethidium bromide-stained agarose gels. A visible band equivalent to 468 base pairs was indicative of a positive PCR result. In none of 28 samples from discarded syringes and none of 10 samples from exchanged syringes was proviral DNA detected (Table 1).TABLE 1: Detection of infectious HIV-1 by a method combining culture and PCR Risk of transmission of HIV-1 to health care workers by accidental needlestick exposure is estimated at 0.3 to 0.4%.8 We have found no published data of transmission after a casual needle stick injury from a discarded syringe left in a public place. Only in a small number of studies is this situation assumed to be a possible risk for transmission of HIV-1.1, 9-11 The inoculum volume of blood is an important factor in the assessment of the possible risk of infection. In a needle stick injury it has been estimated to be between 10 and 100 ml, whereas the inoculum calculated for needle sharing is ∼1 ml.2, 12 If we assume that HIV-1 RNA levels in plasma range from 1 × 102 to 2 × 107 HIV-1 RNA copies per ml of plasma depending on infection stage, in 1 ml there would be fewer than 1 to 104 HIV-1 virions.13 In our study the risk of contracting HIV-1 by needle stick injury from a discarded syringe is zero. This is a significant finding because the syringes studied had been discarded in public places. Although the chances of infection by HIV-1 are very small, prevention and monitoring of the subjects are justified. We do not pretend to estimate the risk of infection because there are many unknown factors involved in intravenous drug use, and the risk can be linked to other aspects such as preservation or origin of syringes. We conclude that there appears to be very little or no risk of HIV-1 infection by casual needle stick injury from a discarded syringe left by an IDU in a public place. Acknowledgments. Work at Centro Nacional de Microbiología was supported by Instituto de Salud Carlos III (Madrid) and Institut Municipal d'Assisténcia Sanitéria (Barcelona). Work in the Hospital del Mar was supported by an FIS grant (94/1071). Asunción Bernal Zamora, Ph.D. Marta Ortiz Rivera, Ph.D. Óscar García-Algar, Ph.D. Joan Caylà Buqueras, Ph.D. Oriol Vall Combelles, Ph.D. Alfredo García-Sáiz, Ph.D. Retrovirus Service; Centro Nacional de Microbiología; Instituto de Salud Carlos III; Madrid, Spain Pediatric Unit; Hospital del Mar; Barcelona, Spain Epidemiology Service; Institut Municipal de la Salut; Barcelona, Spain

References

5