World Archaeology · 2007 · 166 citations · 37 references
Archaeological TheoryPuerto RicoEducationArchaeologyMore TurnHuman SocietiesSocial ’Archaeological RecordOntological MixturesLanguage StudiesArchaeological EvidenceHistorical ArchaeologyArchaeological ReasoningAbstract AbstractPrehistoric ArchaeologyLandscape ReconstructionAnthropologySocial AnthropologyCultural Anthropology
The paper discusses the principle of symmetry in archaeology, reconfiguring the relationship between humans and things within the discipline’s theoretical legacy. It advocates recognizing ontological mixtures of nature and society, centering an equitable study of archaeology’s defining ingredients and arguing that a symmetrical focus reduces epistemological fragmentation. The authors summarize key formulations of this relationship and illustrate how heritage can be rethought under a symmetrical framework. They argue that symmetry of humans and things undercuts many dualisms in recent archaeological theory and practice. Keywords include archaeological reasoning, heritage, symmetry, acknowledgements to SAA participants and scholars, earlier presented at SAA, Puerto Rico, all DISCLAIMERS apply.
Abstract Abstract This paper discusses the principle of symmetry for archaeology in light of the discipline's theoretical legacy. At the core, this principle involves a reconfiguration of how the relationship between humans and things is characterized. Advocating the recognition of mixtures of what are routinely parsed into categories of nature and society, a symmetrical archaeology centres itself upon the equitable study of the discipline's defining ingredients. It is argued that such symmetry of humans and things undercuts many pesky dualisms exhibited throughout the recent history of archaeological theory and practice. The article summarizes the salient formulations of this relationship in archaeological thinking and suggests that a symmetrical focus on ontological mixtures removes the reliance upon multiplying epistemological settlements that fragment the discipline. An example is given of how heritage might be rethought. Keywords: Archaeological reasoningdisciplinary historyheritagescience studiessymmetrythings Acknowledgements An earlier manifestation of this paper was presented at the Society for American Archaeology (SAA) in Puerto Rico. My gratitude goes to the participants of these ‘symmetrical sessions’ and to Don Ihde, Bjørnar Olsen, Chris Witmore and Alison Wylie for insightful discussions. All disclaimers apply.
37
Choice Reviews Online · 1994 · 9.3K citations
Tony Crawford · Configurations · 1994 · 8K citations
Philosophy Of History, Social Change, Contemporary Culture +21
Actor Network Theory and After
David E. Stark, John Law, John Hassard · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 2001 · 3.3K citations