Deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill: Evidence for transinstitutionalization from psychiatric hospitals to penal institutions<sup>1</sup>

Ashley Primeau, Thomas G. Bowers, Marissa A. Harrison, XuXu

Comprehensive Psychology · 2013 · 36 citations · 14 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Since the deinstitutionalization movement, many researchers have suggested that psychiatric patients have moved from one type of institution to another-a process known as transinstitutionalization. This study sought to assess evidence that suggests the mentally ill from Pennsylvania psychiatric hospitals have been transinstitutionalized to penal institutions over the years 1978 to 2010. We gathered data from a number of state agencies and found a significant negative correlation between the incarceration rate and number of psychiatric hospital beds, even after taking into account via partial correlation the changes in population and economic indices such as unemployment and poverty rates in the state. Regression analysis indicated that 6.8% of the year-to-year variation in incarceration rate could be accounted for by the decrease in statewide psychiatric hospital beds after controlling for population and unemployment rate. These transinstitutionalization effects were estimated to cost the state $82.3 million annually. These findings underscore the necessity of providing funding and research towards additional community mental health services for the severely mentally ill so as to avoid adverse outcomes such as incarceration, acute hospitalization, or inefficient state spending. Limitations of the present findings are discussed.

References

14