Comparison of Fatigue Strength of C2 Pedicle Screws, C2 Pars Screws, and a Hybrid Construct in C1–C2 Fixation

Brian W. Su, Adam L. Shimer, Suresh Chinthakunta, Kanaan Salloum, Christopher P. Ames, Alexander R. Vaccaro, Brandon Bucklen

Spine · 2013 · 48 citations · 22 references

Concepts

Abstract

In Brief Study Design. A biomechanical study comparing the fatigue strength of different types of C2 fixation in a C1–C2 construct. Objective. To determine the pullout strength of a C2 pedicle screw and C2 pars screw after cyclical testing and differentiate differences in stiffness pre– and post–cyclical loading of 3 different C1–C2 fixations. Summary of Background Data. Some surgeons use a short C2 pars screw in a C1–C2 construct, because it is less technically demanding and/or when the vertebral artery is high riding. Difference in construct stiffness between use of bilateral C2 pedicle screws, bilateral C2 pars screws, or a hybrid construct is unknown. Methods. Biomechanical testing was performed on 15 specimens. A bicortical C1 lateral mass screw was used in combination with 1 of 3 methods of C2 fixation: (1) bilateral long C2 pedicle screws (LL), (2) bilateral 14-mm C2 pars screws (SS), and (3) unilateral long C2 pedicle screw with a contralateral 14-mm C2 pars screw (LS). Each construct was subject to 16,000 cycles to simulate the immediate postoperative period. Changes in motion in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation were calculated. This was followed by pullout testing. Results. The ability to limit range of motion significantly decreased after cyclical testing in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation for all 3 groups. After loading, the LL and LS groups had less percentage of increase in motion in flexion-extension and lateral bending than the SS group. Overall, the average pullout strength of a pedicle screw was 92% stronger than a pars screw. Conclusion. C2 pedicle screws have twice the pullout strength of C2 pars screws after cyclical loading. In cases in which the anatomy limits placement of bilateral C2 pedicle screws, a construct using a unilateral C2 pedicle screw with a contralateral short pars screw is a viable option and compares favorably with a bilateral C2 pedicle screw construct. Level of Evidence: N/A C2 pedicle screws have almost twice the pullout strength of a C2 pars screw after cyclical loading. Use of bilateral C2 pedicle screws or a unilateral C2 pedicle screw in combination with a contralateral pars screw leads to increased stiffness post—cyclical testing compared with bilateral short C2 pars screws. Therefore, in cases in which the anatomy limits placement of bilateral C2 pedicle screws, a construct using a unilateral C2 pedicle screw with a contralateral short pars screw is a viable option and compares favorably with a bilateral C2 pedicle screw construct.

References

22