Academic Medicine · 2005 · 35 citations · 20 references
Public HealthClinical SciencesMedical EducationEthicsMedical EthicsResearch EthicsClinical EthicsEthical AssessmentEthical Reasoning In ScienceAssessmentsControl Group DesignEducational Intervention EvaluationEthical EvaluationEthical Research PracticeGlobal Assessment FrameworksMatched Control GroupResearch Ethics Education
PURPOSE: Investigators and institutional review boards are entrusted with ensuring the conduct of ethically sound human studies. Assessing ethical aspects of research protocols is a key skill in fulfilling this duty, yet no empirically validated method exists for preparing professionals to attain this skill. METHOD: The authors performed a randomized controlled educational intervention, comparing a criteria-based learning method, a clinical-research- and experience-based learning method, and a control group. All 300 medical students enrolled at the University of New Mexico School of Medicine in 2001 were invited to participate. After a single half-hour educational session, a written posttest of ability to detect ethical problems in hypothetical protocol vignettes was administered. The authors analyzed responses to ten protocol vignettes that had been evaluated independently by experts. For each vignette, a global assessment of the perceived significance of ethical problems and the identification of specific ethical problems were evaluated. RESULTS: Eighty-three medical students (27%) volunteered: 50 (60%) were women and 55 (66%) were first- and second-year students. On global assessments, the criteria-focused group perceived ethical problems as more significant than did the other two groups (p < .02). Students in the criteria-focused group were better able than students in the control group (p < .03) to discern specific ethical problems, more closely resembling expert assessments. Unexpectedly, the group focused on clinical research participants identified fewer problems than did the control group (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: The criteria-focused intervention produced enhanced ethical evaluation skills. This work supports the potential value of empirically derived methods for preparing professionals to discern ethical aspects of human studies.
20
Henry K. Beecher · New England Journal of Medicine · 1966 · 1.9K citations
Public Health, Surgery, Ethics +5
Trust: The Fragile Foundation of Contemporary Biomedical Research
Nancy Kass, Jeremy Sugarman, Ruth Faden et al. · The Hastings Center Report · 1996 · 243 citations
Policies on Faculty Conflicts of Interest at US Universities
Mildred K. Cho · JAMA · 2000 · 227 citations
Ethics and Human Experimentation
David J. Rothman · New England Journal of Medicine · 1987 · 138 citations
Updating Protections for Human Subjects Involved in Research
Jonathan D. Moreno · JAMA · 1998 · 133 citations