Spatial and Temporal Scales in Habitat Selection

Gordon H. Orians, James F. Wittenberger

The American Naturalist · 1991 · 853 citations · 42 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Female yellow-headed blackbirds assess insect production on breeding marshes at settlement, but this complex decision‐making would be missed if analyses were limited to a single spatial scale. The study emphasizes that habitat‑selection analyses must consider multiple spatial scales to avoid misleading interpretations. The birds nest at higher densities on marshes with higher odonate emergence, yet nest‑site selection is driven by vegetation density rather than local food availability, and settlement densities do not correlate with emergence rates at the territory scale.

Abstract

Female yellow-headed blackbirds in eastern Washington State settle to nest at higher densities on marshes with higher emergence rates of odonates, the most important prey delivered to nestlings. However, settling densities of females were not correlated with odonate emergence rates on individual territories or on individual territories plus adjacent ones. Apparently, females assessed production of insects on breeding marshes at the time they settled, and they used this information when making settling decisions. However, they selected nest sites on the basis of vegetation density rather than food availability. The complexity of decision making by female yellowheads would not have been detected had our analysis been restricted to one spatial scale. Because interpretations of habitat selection behavior are scale-dependent, careful attention to scale and performing analyses on more than one spatial scale are essential in studies of habitat selection.

References

42