Choice Reviews Online · 1995 · 195 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesEconomicsHistoryCultural HistoryEconomic HistoryLabor HistoryEmploymentHistory Of WorkIndustrializationLaborMarxist HistoriographyTextile HistoryAdam SmithCollective Action TheoryKarl MarxLabor CultureMarxian Political EconomyPaper MillsTextile MillsWage Labour
The study shows how culture shapes the meaning of labour, using archival evidence to compare wage‑labour development in Western Europe and reinterpret Adam Smith and Karl Marx’s theories, thereby reorienting economic categories. By analysing archival records from Britain, Germany, France, and Italy, the authors demonstrate that the nature of labour as a commodity varied across national contexts and trace divergent developmental pathways to wage labour in Western Europe. Comparing German and British wool mills, the authors find that differing definitions of labour affected industrial work experiences, remuneration, discipline, collective action, and even industrial architecture.
This study demonstrates the power of culture to define the meaning of labour. Drawing on archival evidence from Britain and Germany, as well as historical evidence from France and Italy, the text shows how the very nature of labour as a commodity differed fundamentally in different national contexts. A detailed comparative study of German and British wool textile mills reveals a basic difference in the way labour was understood, even though these industries developed in the same period, used similar machines, and competed in similar markets. These divergent definitions of the essential character of labour as a commodity influenced the entire industrial phenomenon, affecting experiences of industrial work, methods of remuneration, disciplinary techniques, forms of collective action, and even industrial architecture. Starting from a rigorous analysis of detailed archival materials, this study broadens out to analyse the contrasting developmental path ways to wage labour in Western Europe and offers a reinterpretation of theories of political economy put forward by Adam Smith and Karl Marx. In this cross-national study, Richard Biernacki profoundly reorients the analysis of how culture constitutes the very categories of economic life.