Comment on "Resolution of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen and Bell Paradoxes"

Alan Macdonald

Physical Review Letters · 1982 · 22 citations · 1 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

In a recent letter [1], Pitowsky has given a model of electron spin in which “Every electron at each given moment has a definite spin in all directions” but which, he claims, does not imply Bell’s inequality. A non-Kolmogorov probability theory in the model prevents the usual proofs of Bell’s inequality from going through. I give here a very simple proof of a Bell-type inequality from the quoted statement. The inequality shows that the statement is inconsistent with quantum mechanics. Let N pairs of electrons, each with total spin zero, emerge in opposite directions from an interaction. Let N(A : C) be the number of pairs in which the left member has spin up in the A direction and the right member has spin up in the C direction. Let N(A C− :) be the number in which the left member has spin up in the A direction and spin down in the C direction. According to the quoted statement, these are meaningful quantities. Then

References

1