Public Opinion and Policymaking in the States: The Case of Post‐Roe Abortion Policy

Barbara Norrander, Clyde Wilcox

Policy Studies Journal · 1999 · 197 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The influence of public opinion on state abortion legislation is contested, and legislators must navigate conflicting signals from voters, activists, and parties. The study finds that grassroots activism and public opinion align with state abortion policy, with pro‑life laws associated with conservative traditions, Republican majorities, Catholic populations, and fewer women legislators—a pattern consistent across policy indices and funding, while parental‑consent statutes show similar but slightly distinct correlations.

Abstract

Whether public opinion should be expected to play a role in the shaping of abortion legislation in the states is a debatable question. Representation is a difficult task, especially if legislators receive mixed cues from the public, activists, and the political parties. In this study, we find that grass-roots activism and public opinion tend to match, and both are reflected in state abortion policy. In addition, more Pro-Life policies are found in states with a tradition of conservative policies in other areas, Republican majorities in the state legislature, more Catholic residents, and fewer women legislators. These patterns hold true for a composite index of abortion policies and for the specific policy area of government funding of abortions. Slightly different patterns occur for parental consent law, though these statutes also tend to reflect general preferences on abortion and interest group activity in a state.

References

29