Diminishing or durable treatment effects of STARR? A research note on 24-month re-arrest rates

Christopher T. Lowenkamp, Alexander M. Holsinger, Charles Robinson, Melissa Alexander

Journal of Crime and Justice · 2012 · 39 citations · 9 references

Concepts

Abstract

AbstractIn 2009 the Administrative Office of the US Courts developed and piloted a training program (STARR) for probation and pretrial officers. The purpose of this program was to train officers in the use of core correctional practices in their one-on-one interactions with offenders. Two areas of interest were subsequently investigated by researchers. First, did the training impact officer behaviors and second did trained officers supervise offenders that had lower failure rates. The evaluation of this effort was published in 2012 and used a 12-month follow-up for the measure of recidivism. The current study, a research note, extends the follow-up period for recidivism to 24 months. While there is some decline in the overall treatment effects it appears that STARR training is associated with a reduction in recidivism for moderate-risk offenders. Further, when coupled with training in MI, STARR seems to provide a promising reduction in recidivism with high-risk offenders. The limitations of the study and policy implications are discussed.Keywords:: core correctional practicesprobationrecidivism Notes1. The original STARR evaluation was a two group pre-post design. Officers were volunteered for training and were subsequently randomly assigned to training and coaching on STARR. Re-arrest rates of offenders on officers caseloads were calculated for a 12-month-time period prior to the training event and for 12 months after the training event.2. A series of chi-squared tests were run to determine if failure rates of offenders differed by officer. These statistical tests indicate that the failure rates of offenders by officer did not differ during the pre-training time period. The failure rates of offenders by officer did not differ for the control group officers post-training. The failure rates of offenders by officer did differ significantly for trained officers during the post-training time period. This finding is expected as the extent of participation in training events varied by officer as did the level of use of the skills.3. While the data are not present to assess the degree to which officers were using MI we are confident that they were not practicing MI but were possibly using some of the skills associated with MI. We make this assumption based on the results of Alexander, Lowenkamp, Robinson, and Holsinger (2012), which indicates that a very small percentage of officers were able to attain beginning proficiency let alone competence as assessed by the motivational interviewing treatment integrity (MITI) form.4. The two groups of offenders, those supervised by STARR+MI trained officers and those supervised by officers not trained in both STARR+MI, did not differ significantly on race, gender or age. There was a slight difference in RPI score between the two groups (7.29 vs. 7.57 for control and experimental groups respectively), but this difference was borderline in terms of statistical significance (t(218) = 1.8162; p = 0.07).Additional informationNotes on contributorsChristopher T. LowenkampChristopher T. Lowenkamp, PhD is a private consultant and a part-time lecturer at the University of Missouri Kansas City, Department of Criminal Justice & Criminology. Dr. Lowenkamp was previously a probation officer, the director of the Center for Criminal Justice Research at the University of Cincinnati, and a probation administrator for the Administrative Office of the US Courts. His research interests include offender and defendant risk assessment, program evaluation, supervision practices, and the pretrial system. His previous works have appeared in some of the fields' top journals.Alexander HolsingerAlexander (Alex) Holsinger received his PhD in Criminal Justice from the University of Cincinnati in 1999. Throughout his time at the University of Cincinnati (1993 to 1999) and in the 13 years since he has assisted local, state, and Federal agencies in implementing several aspects of Evidence-Based correctional practice. Dr. Holsinger's written work appears in the field's top peer-reviewed journals. Dr. Holsinger has been on faculty in the Department of Criminal Justice & Criminology at University of Missouri – Kansas City since 1999. During his tenure at UMKC, Alex has continued an active publication and research agenda. His teaching areas include the undergraduate and graduate statistics sequences, research methods (specifically methods of program evaluation), correctional rehabilitation and treatment (graduate), community corrections, and criminal justice in the popular media.Charles R. RobinsonCharles R. Robinson is a probation administrator with the Administrative Office of the United States Courts, Office of Probation and Pretrial Services. Prior to working with the Administrative Office he worked as a probation officer in Dallas, Texas. He has focused on developing and training corrections professionals to use cognitive behavioral strategies. He has his Bachelor of Science degree in Criminal Justice from Grambling State University.Melissa AlexanderMelissa Alexander is the Chief US Probation Officer for the Middle District of North Carolina. Her research areas include officer skills training, evidence-based practice, and mental illness/substance abuse within the criminal justice population. She has authored or co-authored articles published in journals such as Federal Probation, the Journal of Crime and Justice, the Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, and the Journal of the National Association of Probation Executives, as well as several book chapters.

References

9