Spatial and temporal dynamics of Aedes aegypti larval sites in Bello, Colombia

Sair Arboleda, Nicolás Jaramillo, A. Townsend Peterson

Journal of Vector Ecology · 2012 · 45 citations · 39 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Counts of immature stages of the mosquito Aedes aegypti have been used to calculate several entomological indices of dengue vector abundance. Some studies have concluded that these indices can be used as indicators of dengue epidemic risk, while other studies have failed to find a predictive relationship. Ecological niche models have been able to predict distributional patterns in space and time, not only of vectors, but also of the diseases that they transmit. In this study, we used Landsat 7 ETM+ images and two niche-modeling algorithms to estimate the local-landscape ecological niche and the dynamics of Ae. aegypti larval habitats in Bello, Colombia, and to evaluate their potential spatial and temporal distribution. Our models showed low omission error with high confidence levels: about 13.4% of the area presents conditions consistently suitable for breeding across the entire study period (2002–2008). The proportion of neighborhoods predicted to be suitable showed a positive association with dengue case rates, whereas the vector-focused Bretau index had no relationship to case rates. As a consequence, niche models appear to offer a superior option for predictive evaluation of dengue transmission risk and anticipating the potential for outbreaks. Aedes aegypti is the main vector of dengue in the world and shows a close association with humans. As such, it is well adapted to urban environments with high human population density and low vegetation coverage (Braks et al. 2003, de Lima-Camara et al. 2006, Honório et al. 2009). In these areas, Ae. aegypti females lay eggs in human-made breeding sites such as used tires, metal drums, recycling containers, and domestic water storage containers (Christophers 1960, Maciel-de-Freitas et al. 2007a,b). The entomological indices commonly used in dengue vector surveillance efforts were developed originally for yellow fever control (“Stegomyia indices”) and focus on immature populations. Examples include the Breteau Index (BI), Container Index (CI), and House Index (HI) (WHO 1997). BI is considered to be the best risk indicator of dengue outbreaks, as it combines information on containers and houses (Tun-Lin et al. 1996). However, several studies have shown that these indices may not always be useful in predicting dengue transmission risk in light of the complex and multifactorial nature of dengue transmission (Focks 2003). BI may be less successful than indices based on pupal stages, since the larval populations on which it focuses do not necessarily translate directly into adult populations (Focks and Barrera 2007). On the other hand, environmental conditions are very important for Ae. aegypti development, both in terms of micro-environments (Gubler 1997) and climate (Peterson et al. 2005), which determine breeding abundance and productivity (Maciel-de-Freitas et al. 2007b). As a result, risk maps based on environmental associations might hold promise. Information extracted from satellite images, and integrated and processed in geographic information systems (GIS), has proven useful in understanding spatial and temporal distributions of vector-borne diseases (Arboleda et al. 2009, Dister et al. 1997, Hayes et al. 1985, Linthicum et al. 1999, Peterson et al. 2005, Wood et al. 1992). One useful paradigm has been that of mapping occurrences, relating them to environmental conditions (the ecological niche), and projecting this “niche model” back onto geography to identify areas of potential distribution (Peterson et al. 2011), which has now been applied in numerous situations of disease transmission (González et al. 2010, Gorla 2002, Larson et al. 2010, Moffett et al. 2007). In the case of dengue, some previous studies have been based on human infections (Arboleda et al. 2009); here, we explore the spatial and temporal dynamics of dengue vector mosquito distributions (Peterson et al. 2005). The purpose of this study is to analyze and estimate the local-landscape ecological niche and dynamics of breeding sites for Aedes aegypti in the municipality of Bello, in the Aburrá Valley region of Antioquia, Colombia, during 2002–2008. After the invasion of Latin America by Ae. aegypti in the early 1970s, the first dengue epidemic in Colombia occurred in 1971. Epidemics in the country have occurred about every four years since then, as in other countries in the Americas. Among municipalities in Colombia, however, Bello has emerged as having environmental and social characteristics that allow near-constant dengue transmission. Our goal is to evaluate the degree to which ecological niche models are able to anticipate the dynamics of breeding by this mosquito species, both across the region and through time, and whether breeding suitability patterns of this vector species translate into variation in human dengue case frequency through time. As part of this aim, we compare the performance of niche models as predictors of human dengue case frequencies with that of the Breteau index. We focused on urban areas within the municipality of Bello, which is part of the greater Medellín metropolitan area, in Antioquia, Colombia, as a study region (Figure 1). This region is of particular interest in light of its high dengue endemicity, with co-circulation of the four dengue serotypes over the last ten years. Bello has a population of 371,973 inhabitants in 97,960 domiciles and covers 19.7 km2. It is divided into 82 neighborhoods grouped into ten communes. Bello is located on a broad, inclined slope that drops from 1,600 to 1,400 m elevation from northwest to southeast, with an average annual temperature of 22° C and annual total rainfall of ∼1,350 mm; no major variation in climatic characteristics exists among neighborhoods. The municipality apparently presents suitable climatic conditions for Ae. aegypti populations; however, at the same time, it has generally good public services, as 96.4% of houses have dedicated water service. The location of Bello municipality, in northern Medellín, Colombia. To make spatially stratified tests, the study area was divided into four quadrants based on the median longitude and latitude of occurrence points of human dengue cases (Arboleda et al. 2009). Points represent mosquito breeding from 2002 for illustration; in spatially stratified tests, points located in dashed quadrants (black circles) were used to train models, and points located in solid quadrants (dotted circles) were used to test them, and vice versa. This procedure was done for each year (2002–2008) and each algorithm (Maxent and GARP). Dengue vector surveillance and control is carried out by the Dirección Local de Salud de Bello (DLSB), which is charged with dengue control in the region. DLSB officials visit samples of 5,709–13,137 houses randomly two to four times yearly to examine water containers and evaluate and eliminate possible mosquito breeding sites. They re-visit houses previously reported as breeding sites to assure that mosquitoes were eliminated, visit houses of patients infected with dengue fever to eliminate point sources, and conduct spraying campaigns. These activities cover the entire municipality. Data regarding sites at which Ae. aegypti was documented as breeding during 2002–2008 were obtained from DLSB sampling of all neighborhoods of Bello. Within each neighborhood, geographic coordinates of sites positive for mosquito breeding were obtained from entomological surveillance by DLSB, which conducted larval surveys according to WHO guidelines (PAHO 1999). The basic unit of sampling was the house, where systematic searches found water containers with larvae, pupae, or exuviae. We employed the Breteau index (BI = number of positive containers per 100 houses inspected) as the infestation indicator in our analyses. It is considered to be the most informative as it establishes a relationship between positive containers and the set of houses inspected (Scott and Morrison 2003). The presence of Ae. aegypti in a water container was the criterion to designate a house as “positive” for breeding. Addresses of houses sampled in the seven years of activity were tabulated, and geographic coordinates assigned using the polygons in the “Plan de Organización Territorial (POT)” of Bello in ArcGIS (version 9.2). A total of 5,709 houses was visited and sampled for mosquitoes, and 2,300 yielded records of Ae. aegypti, of which 2,075 could be georeferenced satisfactorily (i.e., to a precision of ≤20 m) over the study period (Table 1). In 2002–2004, two sampling events were available yearly; in 2005–2008, three sampling events were available yearly (Table 1). Sampling in each year was not necessarily carried out on the same dates. Hence, we decided to condense information by year, both to make analyses more robust and to make possible comparisons among years. To complement information on mosquito breeding sites, we obtained information regarding human dengue cases occurring in Bello in the time frame of one to three weeks after the entomological surveys, and thus took into account the time lag of transmission of the virus. This information was obtained at the level of neighborhoods for each year in 2002–2008 (Table 1). Dengue case information was kindly provided by local health entities (see Acknowledgments), and corresponds to cases that met WHO definitions as at least “suspected” cases (WHO 1997). Symptoms accepted as indicative of probable dengue fever included acute illness with two or more of the following manifestations: headache, retro-orbital pain, myalgia, arthralgia, rash, hemorrhagic manifestations, leucopenia, and supportive serology. The latter evidence was based on a reciprocal hemagglutination-inhibition antibody titer of ≥1,280, a comparable IgG enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) titer, or a positive IgM antibody test on a late-acute or convalescent-phase serum specimen. An additional criterion was occurrence at the same place and time as other confirmed cases of dengue fever (WHO 1997). For geospatial data, we used 23 remotely-sensed images from the ETM+ sensor onboard the Landsat 7 satellite (path/row: 9/56). These images have a spatial resolution of 30 m, and images are in theory available for each site every 16 days, although cloud cover frequently made images unusable. We used bands 1–7 as environmental variables in niche modeling exercises (band 6.1 has a spatial resolution of 60 m, but was resampled to 30 m for consistency with other bands). We a vegetation index using bands and For each year, we the images to the mosquito sampling that showed low cloud of images available and suitable for years (Table 1). images from a year were for analyses. were to the of Bello only (Figure 1). Data on elevation were obtained from the elevation This set has a spatial resolution of m, but was resampled to 30 m for consistency with the Landsat We from this elevation that and slope using the in ArcGIS In then, we used the following to niche models for each year of Landsat bands vegetation and of niche modeling algorithm performance have to identify the algorithm et al. et al. a less well than and not performance of a of the is (Peterson et al. 2007). as (Peterson et al. and accepted to et al. Peterson et al. are both generally evaluation exercises have that to the of predictive of niche As a consequence, in our we used two algorithms to estimate the ecological niche of Ae. aegypti in the Bello region and areas of between the two as a best estimate of suitable conditions and sites and 2007). is a developed to estimate ecological of species based only on presence data, although the of conditions across the study area is used in the The geospatial information available generally the of a set of environmental and distributions are the that of each the average for a set of points from the thus to estimate the distribution for the occurrence of species as the to a to the by environmental conditions with of the species in et al. models were with using of to train models and for the other is robust to sites sampled represent well the environmental of the distributional area and the study area, models generally have good predictive et al. 2006, et al. A suitability is assigned to each which can from to However, one of on ecological predictive of models, and (i.e., local that have is that generally be to by of a et al. 2006, Peterson et al. 2007). occurrence are not which be into account in the of such analyses. In the since immature stages of Ae. aegypti can be with of other mosquito species that in the study area, and some may be or not of where the was we the of occurrence sites that may be such that a is conditions of the by Peterson et al. To into we first the by and them to and a of the of et al. we the potential for error by the that included of occurrence We used that we that our include at as high as As our were (i.e., predicted presence or we used a test to evaluate using as the of the breeding used to train the as the breeding sites that in area as predicted as suitable by and as the the proportion of area predicted as suitable for breeding. The omission error index was as the proportion of breeding sites that not in the area predicted as The for ecological characteristics of occurrence points to of points sampled randomly from the of the study a of that best with by of a algorithm and 1999). Within occurrence points are divided into and evaluation in an of and or A is from a set of and applied to the to or a is on the of the may in that point in predictive between is used to evaluate whether particular be into the the algorithm or To we developed 100 models for each of based on from among available occurrences, each of which was using an of available occurrence set to We a of the models on the of error distributions for models et al. we the models with the omission and the ten of these models with predicted area to the median area predicted among the The geographic of these ten models were on a to a of potential geographic we maps to using the also an error of and the and omission error also as in environmental to be to the (Peterson et al. 2007). This point that the of in environmental For this we the of each of the of variables using a (Peterson and 1999). We models with both algorithms (Maxent and based on of of all each and all possible of We variables for in based on omission error and from After of variables for each year that best predict mosquito we the of each to predict into areas by the study area into four quadrants based on the median longitude and latitude of the occurrence points available to (Figure 1). In these we used points located in the and quadrants to train models, and points in the and quadrants to test the and were also we obtained for and models as we the that the degree of between and test points (i.e., spatial could at as a evaluation of over models based on and spatial were used to a for each year by the from with the from We as potential distributional areas sites where both models in predicting suitability for Ae. aegypti breeding. The of area between and models was by the area predicted as suitable by the total study models for each year were in to identify areas with conditions suitable for breeding through the study period (2002–2008). records from each year were on this to calculate omission error for each year with to these To whether omission error were to the of the area predicted as the additional area predicted as suitable in each year with to the was with these omission error using particular interest was the predictive of our models over time. Hence, we used each yearly to anticipate the spatial distribution of Ae. aegypti breeding sites in years by the niche from each year with mosquito occurrence onto the environmental conditions of years. We for each from both and was the degree to which temporal dynamics of conditions across suitable areas for dengue vector mosquito breeding from area to area among years. we the area predicted as suitable across space for Ae. aegypti breeding with human case rates. The area suitable in each in each year was by the area predicted as suitable by the total area of the For dengue case were as the number of dengue cases occurring within one to three weeks after the sampling period in the divided by the population provided by We used to test for between human case and area predicted by the models as suitable for mosquito breeding. In we of the Breteau Index with dengue case by and the area predicted as also using of and models based on showed that some variables do not to as in or of models based on variables and and (Table Hence, we that bands and are useful We found associations between of georeferenced breeding sites and area predicted as suitable for Ae. aegypti breeding with omission error for of occurrence in and of the study area for and (Table models generally showed omission than models, but models to identify more areas (Figure these are with the that models identify areas that are and more than models and Peterson Ecological niche of suitable areas for Aedes aegypti breeding in each year as predicted using and and based on the of the two The spatially stratified of the of models in each year to predict into areas predictive In in all cases of in were than The were as in the predicting area was to predict points than and in 2005, the predicting area was to predict points than (Table For models in this had omission error of and that of the study area, while models had omission error of and that of the of the best and models for each year that the area of between the two from to of the municipality. The yearly models for each year in 13.4% of the total area of Bello as consistently suitable for Ae. aegypti breeding across all years (Figure area predicted by models for years greater than the that to of yearly suitable area is consistently suitable for Ae. aegypti breeding. breeding sites were on the omission error were high (Table breeding in areas of the However, omission showed no association with additional area predicted that the of the area predicted not determine omission rates. areas as consistently suitable for Aedes aegypti breeding across the municipality of Bello by both and models across all years. yearly models showed good to anticipate breeding mosquito distributions in other years than with omission error for In omission error as the evaluation year more in time from the year (Table more predictive onto the environmental conditions of the year in However, omission for models to the environmental conditions of the years as with omission for models not but applied to the occurrence of other we that in of cases omission were with the models, which is not from omission error were in other all could predict of test The of mosquito breeding sites can be used to anticipate of human dengue Our showed a positive between area predicted as suitable by models and dengue case in all years and However, BI was not to dengue case in year areas in each predicted as suitable were also not to BI in year mosquito breeding is one of the most used to risk of dengue outbreaks, the of these indicators as transmission risk has been (Focks and 1997, et al. 1996). However, these indicators have been used to the of the disease and The municipality of Bello is not an entomological indices are used to dengue risk, the association between entomological indices and dengue case is not well In this study, we for such and found We whether models based on information can predict the spatial and temporal dynamics of mosquito breeding. mosquito breeding is also by conditions and human conditions in mosquito breeding mosquito development, and within Our showed that these models in anticipating breeding distributions in space and time consistently than at The that we employed the of models to anticipate distributions of breeding mosquitoes across areas from which no sampling is as such, it directly to the to sampling to and anticipate breeding distributions in other The has been used with in other spatial distribution studies conducted by Peterson et al. for dengue in and by et al. with human dengue cases in Bello, Colombia. Our to predict presence of breeding vector populations in areas is as it to and and their in and control both niche modeling algorithms well in these tests, studies of and have shown that at some level (Peterson et al. however, areas predicted as suitable by the two algorithms at least in In the two models only by however, for the other the (Table This area from two could suitable sites for Ae. aegypti breeding with greater The based on from all years showed that only 13.4% of Bello was consistently suitable for Ae. aegypti breeding through time. The that is that breeding suitability is in a that on both human and environmental the additional area predicted as suitable in a year this area was not with omission error we out the that area predicted on used in each year to the As an important of niche modeling is its predictive through time and over the spatial showed that our models the spatial In tests, we the of models to predict through time, and our showed that models in one year had good predictive for other years. conditions predicted as suitable in a particular year can anticipate Ae. aegypti breeding sites in other years than at the time is not The were good within years (i.e., from one year to the or to a for that were more in time, we obtained omission some degree of for This generally good the of anticipating spatial patterns of dengue vector breeding from one year to the by of ecological niche it is important to be able to predict mosquito breeding in space and time, such are more they with patterns of occurrence of human dengue cases in space and time, an indicator of transmission The the showed no association to number of human dengue cases or to area as suitable in our models within neighborhoods. In from our models were with of human dengue cases by neighborhood, as was found in a previous study at spatial in (Peterson et al. 2005). our models in low the dengue case occurrences, we found it since the area predicted as suitable for breeding not directly to the distribution of adult mosquito populations in our study area et al. These the of and Barrera that occurrence of immature stages of mosquitoes not the of dengue transmission risk at all However, some with this is other such as of human populations can an important in dengue which could predictive with entomological indices et al. Some previous studies have developed spatial or temporal models based on mosquito using Landsat images to predict larval indices of Ae. aegypti et al. have developed models for mosquito breeding based on to with human and using niche modeling algorithms to risk that to be than et al. However, they not test the of models to predict into areas, and used to evaluate predictive of the models, which have several et al. Peterson et al. Honório et al. developed models to dengue case to mosquito in three neighborhoods of de but found no which they to the that infections had occurred at sites other than the based on entomological have been able to predict mosquito breeding productivity et al. these studies areas for larval they not to dengue case to evaluate their et al. developed a to of dengue in areas of They such as dengue in vector and transmission and concluded that human is an important in dengue transmission. these previous our could predict mosquito larval habitats in space and time, and showed some with dengue case rates, which to their This study on to a of the same (Peterson et al. and at that mosquito can for sampling activities can be indices These may not be an of vector surveillance et al. We to and of the Bello of for their of dengue cases and Ae. aegypti breeding also to of the Bello of for of for the municipality. for this was provided by de de and de and de de Antioquia, Colombia.

References

39