The selective advantage of reaction norms for environmental tolerance

Wilfried Gabriel, Michael Lynch

Journal of Evolutionary Biology · 1992 · 156 citations · 5 references

Concepts

TL;DR

A tolerance curve describes how a genotype’s fitness depends on an environmental gradient, is defined by an optimal environment (mode) and a breadth of adaptation (width), and may be adaptively altered during development. The authors extend environmental‑tolerance theory by incorporating reaction norms for both the mode and the width of the tolerance curve. Selective value of these reaction norms increases with spatial heterogeneity and inter‑generational temporal variation, decreases with intra‑generational variation, and, although maintaining broad adaptation is costly, the norms induce correlated selection for reduced breadth, producing a near one‑to‑one relationship between optimal breadth and perceived within‑generation variation, implying that breadth estimates can serve as an index of organism‑perceived environmental variability.

Abstract

Abstract A tolerance curve defines the dependence of a genotype's fitness on the state of an environmental gradient. It can be characterized by a mode (the genotype's optimal environment) and a width (the breadth of adaptation). It seems possible that one or both of these characters can be modified in an adaptive manner, at least partially, during development. Thus, we extend the theory of environmental tolerance to include reaction norms for the mode and the width of the tolerance curve. We demonstrate that the selective value of such reaction norms increases with increasing spatial heterogeneity and between‐generation temporal variation in the environment and with decreasing within‐generation temporal variation. Assuming that the maintenance of a high breadth of adaptation is costly, reaction, norms are shown to induce correlated selection for a reduction in this character. Nevertheless, regardless of the magnitude of the reaction norm, there is a nearly one to one relationship between the optimal breadth of adaptation and the within‐generation temporal variation perceived by the organism. This suggests that empirical estimates of the breadth of adaptation may provide a useful index of this type of environmental variation from the organism's point of view.

References

5