Transforming Inner-City Landscapes

TLDR

Law enforcement officials claim that vegetation in inner‑city neighborhoods increases fear. The study examines how inner‑city residents respond to adding trees and grass in their neighborhoods. The authors manipulated tree density, placement, and grass maintenance in photo simulations and had 100 nearby residents rate the images for preference and safety. Tree density and grass maintenance strongly increased both preference and sense of safety, indicating that vegetation can enhance safety perceptions in inner‑city neighborhoods.

Abstract

How would inner-city residents respond to the incorporation of trees and grass in their neighborhoods? Law enforcement officials have argued that, in these settings, trees and other forms of vegetation increase fear. Tree density, tree placement, and levels of grass maintenance were manipulated in photo simulations of neighborhood outdoor space. One hundred residents of Chicago's Robert Taylor Homes living adjacent to the space rated the images with respect to preference and sense of safety. Although tree placement (subspaces created by trees, formality of arrangement) had little effect on sense of safety and no effect on preference, both tree density and grass maintenance had strong effects on preference and sense of safety (η 2 s from .49 to .89). Surprisingly, tree density and grass maintenance increased both preference and sense of safety. Results suggest that-contrary to some views-trees and grass maintenance can increase sense of safety in inner-city neighborhoods.