Logarithmic Lower Bounds in the Cell-Probe Model

Abstract

We develop a new technique for proving cell-probe lower bounds on dynamic data structures. This technique enables us to prove an amortized randomized $\Omega(\lg n)$ lower bound per operation for several data structural problems on n elements, including partial sums, dynamic connectivity among disjoint paths (or a forest or a graph), and several other dynamic graph problems (by simple reductions). Such a lower bound breaks a long-standing barrier of $\Omega(\lg n\,/\lg\lg n)$ for any dynamic language membership problem. It also establishes the optimality of several existing data structures, such as Sleator and Tarjan's dynamic trees. We also prove the first $\Omega(\log_B n)$ lower bound in the external-memory model without assumptions on the data structure (such as the comparison model). Our lower bounds also give a query-update trade-off curve matched, e.g., by several data structures for dynamic connectivity in graphs. We also prove matching upper and lower bounds for partial sums when parameterized by the word size and the maximum additive change in an update.