Philosophy and Phenomenological Research · 2012 · 46 citations · 29 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyPhilosophy Of MindEssentialismNormative EthicsEssential Properties Of PersonsEssentialist Accounts Of Normality
Dispositional essentialists argue that physical properties have their causal roles essentially. This is typically taken to mean that physical properties are identical to dispositions. I argue that this is untenable, and that we must instead say that properties bestow dispositions. I explore what it is for a property to have such a role essentially. Dispositional essentialists argue for their view by citing certain epistemological and metaphysical implications, and I appeal to these implications to place desiderata on the concept of essence involved. I argue that the traditional modal theory of essence meets these desiderata, but that the resulting theory wrongly implies that certain dispositions essential to mass are essential to charge, thereby offering a new argument against modal theories of essence. I argue that dispositional essentialism requires a primitive notion of essence, and develop a primitivist theory based on Kit Fine's views. I show that the primitivist theory has all the virtues of the modal alternative, and none of the vices. I develop a novel way of thinking about the relationship between properties, laws and dispositions, and argue that it has distinct advantages over standard dispositional essentialist formulations.
29
Alvin I. Goldman, Robert Nozick · The Philosophical Review · 1983 · 2.1K citations
Essence and Modality: The Second Philosophical Perspectives Lecture
Kit Fine · Philosophical Perspectives · 1994 · 1.4K citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Hermeneutics +10
Lenny Clapp, Brian Ellis · The Philosophical Review · 2002 · 708 citations
David Lewis · The Philosophical Quarterly · 1997 · 460 citations
Three theses about dispositions
Elizabeth W. Prior, Robert Pargetter, Frank Jackson · American Philosophical Quarterly · 1982 · 383 citations