Quality versus Quantity: The Case of Forward-Looking Disclosure

Sergio Beretta, Saverio Bozzolan

Journal of Accounting Auditing & Finance · 2008 · 49 citations · 31 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Empirical studies have not clearly distinguished between the quantity and quality of disclosure, and although quantity is often used as a proxy, measuring quality remains an open question that literature stresses the need to address. This paper contests the view that disclosure quantity reliably indicates quality, proposes a multidimensional quality index, and hypothesizes that higher quality disclosure improves forecast accuracy while reducing analysts’ earnings forecast dispersion. The authors construct a multidimensional framework and develop an index to quantify disclosure quality. Analytical results show that the quality index captures dimensions useful for earnings forecasting and is more strongly positively associated with forecast accuracy and more strongly negatively associated with forecast dispersion than a simple quantity index.

Abstract

Empirical studies do not make a clear distinction between the quantity and quality of disclosure. As it is generally assumed that the quantity of information has an implication in determining its quality, quantity measures are often used as proxy for disclosure quality. Nonetheless, the measurement of the quality of disclosure is recognized as a relevant question that is still open and the importance of developing measures of disclosure quality is emphasized in literature. This paper disputes the idea that the quantity of disclosure is a sound proxy for the quality of disclosure. The adoption of multidimensional frameworks for the appreciation of disclosure is discussed and an index for quality disclosure is proposed. Moving from the assumption that high-quality information should usefully support external users in the judgment of past and future performance, we hypothesize that high-quality disclosure is positively associated with accuracy and negatively associated with the dispersion of analysts' earnings forecasts. We show analytically that the proposed framework captures dimensions of annual report disclosure that are considered useful by financial analysts in forecasting earnings and that the proposed measure of disclosure quality has a stronger positive statistical association with accuracy and a stronger negative association with the dispersion of financial analysts' earnings forecasts than a simple index of disclosure quantity has.

References

31