Public Administration Review · 2015 · 185 citations · 29 references
Social SciencesPolitical SciencePsychologyBehavioral EconomicsDecision TheoryPolitical BehaviorBiasPolitical KnowledgeEvaluations Of Government PerformanceGovernment Performance EvaluationGovernment Performance MeasurementInformation BiasPerformance Information DisclosurePerformance Information QualityPolitical Information ProcessingRandomized Experiments
Abstract A main rationale of performance information is to empower citizens to make informed decisions by presenting them with unambiguous information about the performance of institutions. However, even objective, clear, and unambiguous performance information is subject to biased interpretation depending on whether the information is consistent with the prior beliefs held by those who receive the information. Integrating the theory of motivated reasoning with the literature on performance information, the authors hypothesize that performance information that is inconsistent with prior beliefs is less likely to be interpreted correctly than belief‐consistent information. Using randomized survey experiments in which respondents were presented with quantitative performance data, the authors show that subjects systematically interpret performance information in ways that conform with their prior beliefs. The findings question the assumption that providing performance information automatically increases knowledge about government performance, let alone improves political decisions.
29
Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk
Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky · Econometrica · 1979 · 47K citations
The Science of "Muddling Through"
Charles E. Lindblom · Public Administration Review · 1959 · 8.2K citations
Herbert A. Simon · Economica · 1957 · 1.3K citations
Drew Westen, Pavel S. Blagov, Keith A. Harenski et al. · Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience · 2006 · 498 citations