The American Journal of Sports Medicine · 2000 · 45 citations · 16 references
MedicineOrthopaedic SurgeryOrthopedic SurgeryAdult ReconstructionOrthopedic RehabilitationOrthopedicsLigament ReconstructionOrthopedic ExaminationAnterior Cruciate Ligament TestsCorrelationJoint LaxityKnee Function AssessmentKnee Joint AssessmentLigament Reconstruction AssessmentSide-by-side ComparisonSide-to-side Comparison
Forty-four patients who had undergone unilateral anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions were evaluated retrospectively with seven different scoring systems (International Knee Documentation Committee, Orthopadische Arbeitsgruppe Knie, Lysholm, Feagin and Blake, Zarins and Rowe, Cincinnati, and Marshall scores). The results varied between systems and therefore lacked reliability. Of the 44 patients, 32 were rated as excellent according to the Cincinnati score while only 3 patients were rated as normal according to the International Knee Documentation Committee form. Good and excellent results were found twice as frequently with the Cincinnati and Lysholm scores compared with the scores of Zarins and Rowe or the International Knee Documentation Committee form. Statistical analysis confirmed this observation and revealed significant differences between the scoring systems. Side-to-side differences using the manual maximum displacement test with the KT-1000 arthrometer revealed good correlation with the International Knee Documentation Committee and the Orthopadische Arbeitsgruppe Knie questionnaires. None of the other scoring systems, which do not measure anterior laxity, produced reasonable correlation with instrumented measurements. We found that certain population-specific factors as well as the distribution of single findings can distort the results of scoring systems. To avoid these interference factors, the patient sample should be homogeneous and selected prospectively and there should be agreement about the value of single findings.
16
Instrumented measurement of anterior laxity of the knee.
Dale M. Daniel, Lawrence Malcom, Gary M. Losse et al. · Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery · 1985 · 750 citations