Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology · 2014 · 20 citations · 31 references
ComputingData ScienceKnowledge RepresentationSemanticsVocabulary DevelopmentControlled VocabulariesDescription LogicsFormal OntologyOntology DesignOntology EngineeringOntologiesThesauriThesaurus UseWeb Ontology Language
Thesauri and other types of controlled vocabularies are increasingly re‐engineered into ontologies described using the Web Ontology Language (OWL), particularly in the life sciences. This has led to the perception by some that thesauri are ontologies once they are described by using the syntax of OWL while others have emphasized the need to re‐engineer a vocabulary to use it as ontology. This confusion is rooted in different perceptions of what ontologies are and how they differ from other types of vocabularies. In this article, we rigorously examine the structural differences and similarities between thesauri and meaning‐defining ontologies described in OWL. Specifically, we conduct (a) a conceptual comparison of thesauri and ontologies, and (b) a comparison of a specific thesaurus and a specific ontology in the same subject field. Our results show that thesauri and ontologies need to be treated as 2 orthogonal kinds of models with superficially similar structures. An ontology is not a good thesaurus, nor is a thesaurus a good ontology. A thesaurus requires significant structural and other content changes to become an ontology, and vice versa.
31
The Description Logic Handbook – Theory, Implementation and Applications
C.J.H. Mann · Kybernetes · 2003 · 2.2K citations
Relations in biomedical ontologies
Barry Smith, Werner Ceusters, Bert R. E. Klagges et al. · Genome biology · 2005 · 1K citations · Full text
Computing, Biomedical Informatics, Health Data Interoperability +14
SNAP and SPAN: Towards Dynamic Spatial Ontology
Pierre Grenon, Barry Smith · Spatial Cognition and Computation · 2004 · 609 citations · Full text