Giving Sex

Georgiann Davis, Jodie M. Dewey, Erin L. Murphy

Gender & Society · 2015 · 103 citations · 30 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Medical providers use similar tools to treat intersex and trans individuals, but their medicalization practices differ. The study aims to deconstruct the complexities of medicalization practices for intersex and trans individuals. This is achieved through a comparative analysis of providers specializing in intersex and trans medicine. Both intersex and trans providers hold essentialist views and medicalize differently—intersex providers treat intersex as an emergency requiring medical attention, while trans providers seek to delay urgent transition requests—yet in both cases they “give gender” by “giving sex,” shifting responsibility onto parents or adult patients, and successful interventions align with heteronormative gender practices.

Abstract

Although medical providers rely on similar tools to “treat” intersex and trans individuals, their enactment of medicalization practices varies. To deconstruct these complexities, we employ a comparative analysis of providers who specialize in intersex and trans medicine. While both sets of providers tend to hold essentialist ideologies about sex, gender, and sexuality, we argue they medicalize intersex and trans embodiments in different ways. Providers for intersex people are inclined to approach intersex as an emergency that necessitates medical attention, whereas providers for trans people attempt to slow down their patients’ urgent requests for transitioning services. Building on conceptualizations of “giving gender,” we contend both sets of providers “give gender” by “giving sex.” In both cases too, providers shift their own responsibility for their medicalization practices onto others: parents in the case of intersex, or adult recipients of care in the case of trans. According to the accounts of most providers, successful medical interventions are achieved when a person adheres to heteronormative gender practices.

References

30