American Journal of Psychiatry · 1992 · 327 citations · 26 references
Social SciencesPsychiatryPsychologyAbnormal PsychologyPersonality PsychologyPsychiatric AssessmentCo-occurring DisordersComorbidityDiagnostic InterviewingPersonality DisordersPsychiatric DiagnosisPsychopathology AssessmentBorderline Personality Disorder ComorbidityClinical ComorbidityConfidence Intervals For Odds RatiosHistrionic Personality DisorderPersonality Disorder DiagnosisPersonality Disorders DiagnosisPsychiatric Comorbidity AssessmentStructured Diagnostic Interviews
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to examine patterns of co-occurrence of axis II disorders in a group of consecutive patients evaluated with two contrasting structured interviews. METHOD: One hundred of 106 consecutive applicants for long-term, inpatient treatment of severe personality psychopathology were assessed, face-to-face, by psychiatrists using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R Personality Disorders (SCID-II) and the Personality Disorder Examination (PDE). The percent of co-occurrence of pairs of disorders diagnosed by each structured interview separately was calculated, and significance levels were determined by using chi-square tests of independence. Finally, odds ratios were computed for the odds of each pair of disorders occurring together compared with the odds for the occurrence of each disorder alone. RESULTS: The two interview methods revealed different comorbidity patterns. Significant covariation was found for 29 pairs of disorders diagnosed with the PDE, compared with 12 pairs diagnosed with the SCID-II. Six pairs of disorders covaried significantly and were associated with odds ratios greater than 4: histrionic with borderline, histrionic with narcissistic, narcissistic with antisocial, narcissistic with passive-aggressive, avoidant with schizotypal, and avoidant with dependent. CONCLUSIONS: Substantial overlap occurred among personality disorders. In this group of patients, consistent patterns of comorbidity involving narcissistic, avoidant, and histrionic personality disorders suggest that categorical distinctions between them and certain other DSM-III-R personality disorders may be illusory. The question of which of two overlapping disorders is more valid, however, is left unanswered. For clinical purposes, a two-level diagnostic convention is proposed.
26
Statistical Methods for Rates and Proportions.
B. S. Everitt, J. L. Fleiss · Biometrics · 1981 · 9.1K citations
The Validity of DSM-III Borderline Personality Disorder
Harrison G. Pope · Archives of General Psychiatry · 1983 · 463 citations
The Personality Disorder Examination: A Preliminary Report
Armand W. Loranger, Virginia L. Susman, John M. Oldham et al. · Journal of Personality Disorders · 1987 · 313 citations