A comparative evaluation of AMQP and MQTT protocols over unstable and mobile networks

Jorge E. Luzuriaga, Miguel Ángel Pérez-Martín, Pablo Boronat, Juan‐Carlos Cano, Carlos T. Calafate, Pietro Manzoni

2015 · 150 citations · 10 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Message oriented middleware (MOM) supports sending and receiving messages between distributed systems, with AMQP and MQTT being the most relevant protocols; they are widely used for exchanging messages by abstracting system entities, simplifying coordination and programming, yet they have not been thoroughly tested in mobile or dynamic networks such as vehicular networks, making this evaluation important for future IoT applications. This paper experimentally evaluates AMQP and MQTT in mobile or dynamic networks to characterize their behavior in terms of message loss, latency, jitter, and saturation boundary values. The authors conduct experiments measuring message loss, latency, jitter, and saturation limits of both protocols in mobile and dynamic network environments. The results provide criteria for selecting the appropriate protocol and assess their performance and viability.

Abstract

Message oriented middleware (MOM) refers to the software infrastructure supporting sending and receiving messages between distributed systems. AMQP and MQTT are the two most relevant protocols in this context. They are extensively used for exchanging messages since they provide an abstraction of the different participating system entities, alleviating their coordination and simplifying the communication programming details. These protocols, however, have not been thoroughly tested in the context of mobile or dynamic networks like vehicular networks. In this paper we present an experimental evaluation of both protocols in such scenarios, characterizing their behavior in terms of message loss, latency, jitter and saturation boundary values. Based on the results obtained, we provide criteria of applicability of these protocols, and we assess their performance and viability. This evaluation is of interest for the upcoming applications of MOM, especially to systems related to the Internet of Things.

References

10