Sibling Relationships in the College Years: Do Gender, Birth Order, and Age Spacing Matter?

Michele Van Volkom, Carly Machiz, Ashley E. Reich

North American journal of psychology · 2011 · 25 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

The study of sibling relationships beyond childhood has been steadily receiving more attention from researchers in recent decades. Relationships between men and women, parents and their children, and grandparents and their grandchildren have been the main focus of researchers in the past. However, it has been argued for decades that the types of relationships that exist between siblings, especially adult siblings, have relatively limited information available (Myers & Bryant, 2008a; Pulakos, 1989; Spitze & Trent, 2006). It is important to study all stages of life when dealing with relationships between siblings because that type of relationship evolves from childhood to elder years (Cicirelli, 2009; Newman, 1994; Panish & Stricker, 2001; Riggio, 2000, 2001; Spitze & Trent, 2006; Van Volkom, 2006). The study of sibling relationships is extremely important because when linking sibling relationships in childhood to sibling relationships in adulthood, conclusions can be drawn about the impact that siblings have on one another's lives (Milevsky, 2004; Shortt & Gottman, 1997). No two sibling relationships are identical. Most are very healthy (Martin, Anderson, & Rocca, 2005), but some result in violence (Myers & Goodboy, 2010), conflict (Newman, 1994; Sherman, Lansford, & Volling, 2006), hostility (Milevsky, Smoot, Leh, & Ruppe, 2005) and verbal aggression (Myers & Bryant, 2008b). Since the sibling relationship is forced, unlike a friendship which is voluntary, there are many dynamics involved (Martin et al., 2005; Newman, 1994). The rivalry experienced in childhood may continue into adulthood (Myers & Goodboy, 2010). This rivalry may partly be due to the effect of parental favoritism. For example, Rauer and Volling (2007) reported that when parental affection differed among siblings, the impact on the siblings was negative, both in terms of the self and in later romantic relationships. Earlier work by Boll, Ferring, and Filipp (2003) found that when favoritism was displayed, the quality of the relationship between siblings deteriorated. However, once siblings age, they generally have a positive relationship (Martin et al., 2005) and rely on each other for both instrumental and emotional support (Van Volkom, 2006). There are many theories underlying the sibling relationship. For example, although events like marriage and raising a family may make sibling contact less frequent during adulthood, attachment theory posits that siblings maintain an emotional bond with each other throughout their lifetime. Moreover, it has been suggested that this bond may continue even after a sibling dies (Bowlby, 1980; Cicirelli, 2009). The buffering hypothesis suggests that an individual may seek out a closer bond with a sibling as a buffer against stressful occurrences in the family, such as parental divorce (Bush & Ehrenberg, 2003; Milevsky, 2004; Riggio, 2001). Adult siblings can be essential resources for support, love, and friendship (Connidis, 1992; Martin et al., 2005; Riggio, 2000, 2001; Shortt & Gottman, 1997; White & Riedmann, 1992). In a large study of adult siblings in the United States, sixty-six percent of the participants said that their sibling was a close friend, fifty percent of adults said that at least once a month they had contact with their sibling, and thirty-three percent of adults stated that they could depend on their sibling in case of an emergency (Voorpostel & Blieszner, 2008). When siblings do not have a good relationship with their parents, they tend to overcompensate by having a supportive relationship with one another. Support and warmth is different between men and women (Milevsky et al., 2005). Women are more likely to give emotional support, especially to sisters (Spitze & Trent, 2006; Voorpostel & Blieszner, 2008). Cicirelli (1995) explored the importance of close relationships between adult siblings and how it can support a more fulfilling and enjoyable life, even in the elderly stages of life. …