Evidence from panel unit root and cointegration tests that the Environmental Kuznets Curve does not exist

Roger Perman, David I. Stern

Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics · 2003 · 69 citations · 44 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The Environmental Kuznets Curve posits an inverted‑U relationship between environmental degradation and income, a stylised fact that has faced theoretical and empirical criticism, and cointegration analysis can test its validity when data exhibit stochastic trends. The study tests the EKC hypothesis by applying cointegration analysis to a panel of sulfur emissions and GDP for 74 countries over 31 years. Using cointegration analysis on a 31‑year panel of 74 countries, the authors treat the EKC as a long‑run equilibrium that requires a cointegrating model where sulfur emissions are a concave function of income. The analysis shows that the data are stochastically trending, panel and individual cointegration tests cast doubt on the EKC, and even when cointegration holds, most country relationships are not concave, indicating the EKC is problematic for sulfur emissions.

Abstract

The Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) hypothesis – an inverted U‐shape relation between various indicators of environmental degradation and income per capita – has become one of the ‘stylised facts’ of environmental and resource economics. This is despite considerable criticism on both theoretical and empirical grounds. Cointegration analysis can be used to test the validity of such stylised facts when the data involved contain stochastic trends. In the present paper, we use cointegration analysis to test the EKC hypothesis using a panel dataset of sulfur emissions and GDP data for 74 countries over a span of 31 years. We find that the data is stochastically trending in the time‐series dimension. Given this, and interpreting the EKC as a long run equilibrium relationship, support for the hypothesis requires that an appropriate model cointegrates and that sulfur emissions are a concave function of income. Individual and panel cointegration tests cast doubt on the general applicability of the hypothesised relationship. Even when we find cointegration, many of the relationships for individual countries are not concave. The results show that the EKC is a problematic concept, at least in the case of sulfur emissions.

References

44