Given the <scp>W</scp>eb, What is Intelligence, Really?

Selmer Bringsjord, Naveen Sundar Govindarajulu

Metaphilosophy · 2012 · 21 citations · 7 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Existing Web systems cannot reach human‑level intelligence without genuine problem solving on unseen problems. The article argues that achieving human‑level intelligence requires committing to a strong intensional logic. The authors present a novel mathematical argument that extensional systems cannot capture natural language complexity, using increasingly complex first‑order language representations. Attempts at representation fail to achieve consistency, underscoring the need for an intensional representation system for natural language.

Abstract

Abstract This article argues that existing systems on the W eb cannot approach human‐level intelligence, as envisioned by D escartes, without being able to achieve genuine problem solving on unseen problems. The article argues that this entails committing to a strong intensional logic. In addition to revising extant arguments in favor of intensional systems, it presents a novel mathematical argument to show why extensional systems can never hope to capture the inherent complexity of natural language. The argument makes its case by focusing on representing, with increasing degrees of complexity, knowledge in a first‐order language. Nevertheless, the attempts at representation fail to achieve consistency, making the case for an intensional representation system for natural language clear.

References

7