The Negro educational review · 2011 · 23 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesGender StudiesEthnographyFeminist TheoryWomen's StudiesFeminist CriticismStandpoint TheoryInstitutional Change Mechanisms
Tedious Journeys: Autoethnography by Women of Color in Academe Edited by Cynthia Cole Robinson and Pauline Clardy New York: Peter Lang Publishers, 2010, 1999 pp. $32.95 paperback In the book, Tedious Journeys: Autho ethnography by Women of Color in Academe, the appropriateness of the adjective tedious resonates across the chapters. Regardless of the positions and level of commitment from which these authors' pursue success in academia, their unfolding journeys have been laced with knots. They describe circumstances that strain what could, for them, be more fluid progressions across their roles and statuses in academia. This book documents the myriad ways in which these women are stymied in their advancement due to overt and covert exchanges of power among students and their parents, faculty, staff, and also administrators whose positions of privilege can extend into community and professional realms. At the same time that these women in academe present change (i.e., inclusion), they can also present a threat of change. Those who perceive themselves as entitled actors or at least tokens in the production of knowledge may sense their viability is at risk when the institution begins to reflect the cultural, linguistic, and epistemological plurality of the global population. However, presence and possibility do not always represent change in institutional or personal values. For instance, in the book, Chavez describes her work as a dean of students and the inability of universities to honor the ways in which she interprets her professional duties and infuses them with cultural knowledge. Additionally, Randolph's account of navigating student evaluations from courses on diversity to research methods, suggests that work (in) academia requires some disentanglement of knots - especially those that result from the permanence of racism and gender inequities. Further, in an account by Brown concerning a student complaint, a supervisor asked her: What could you have done differently? Instead the administrator might have asked what she encountered and how she responded. As the former she was placed on the defensive and the communication was shrouded by a kind of professionalism (which feigns race and gender neutrality) and proceeded from the perspective that her power was unchallenged. Instead, as she reveals, her power was challenged by multiple actors operating collaboratively from different positions of privilege. Although the discourse directed by the supervisor drew a particular response, Brown shares with the audience her differently filtered response. Regardless of the social and professional positions in academe, one can learn from both communications about which questions and responses are deemed appropriate and how the assumptions which undergird them help to sustain conditions that are disproportionately and repeatedly harmful to some groups. Many of these women scholars are taxed professionally and emotionally so as to induce stress which can create health problems or exacerbate preexisting conditions that can negatively impact performance. Although each scholar appears to have overcome many setbacks, which is to be applauded, they provoke us to ask whether we too often suffer in silence. The individual lens of the autoethnographic method coupled with the research in which these women authors have grounded these accounts speaks to need for institutional change. In fact, the editors and authors echo a desire to use this book to inform aspiring scholars and other institutional representatives seeking a change in an academic culture fraught with struggles. The chapters in this book reflect an academic culture that marginalizes these women in a way that is more tedious than not, or necessary. Keeping in mind their already tenuous circumstances in academia we are encouraged by this collection of chapters to ask the following questions: What are the possibilities for dialogue about racism and sexism in the academy? …