2014 · 19 citations · 16 references
EngineeringCivil EngineeringCondition AssessmentMechanical Behavior Of MaterialsPavement EngineeringAsphalt MaterialsPavement DesignPavement EvaluationPavement MaterialsPavement Performance AnalysisShear StrengthAsphalt BinderDeformationHot Mix AsphaltMixture Performance EvaluationRutting AnalysisShear FailureShear ResistanceShear Stress
Traditionally run at one test temperature (122°F), the Hamburg wheel tracking test (HWTT) has a proven history of identifying hot mix asphalt (HMA) mixes that are moisture susceptible and/or prone to rutting. However, with the record summer temperatures of the recent years, several shear and rutting failures have occurred with HMA mixes that had passed the HWTT in the laboratory. For the most part, failures occurred in high shear locations, particularly with slow-moving traffic at controlled intersections (accelerating/decelerating), stop-go sections, elevated temperatures, heavy/high traffic loading, and where lower performance grade (PG) asphalt-binder grades have been used. This two-year study was undertaken to improve the performance of the existing laboratory rutting-shear tests including the HWTT in simulating the field rutting conditions of the HMA and exploring new supplementary and/or surrogate HMA rutting/shear tests. In particular, a potential surrogate test should be able to discriminate HMA mixture performance for application in high shear stress areas (i.e., intersections) as well as discern temperature thresholds at which a given HMA mix, with a given PG asphalt-binder grade, becomes unstable and more prone to rutting and/or shear failure. In line with these objectives, this final project report documents the research work completed in this study. Several of the existing HMA rutting-shear tests were comprehensively evaluated with special focus on the HWTT. Researchers propose several enhancements to the HWTT protocol that are expected to improve its overall performance in predicting HMA rutting susceptibility. Additionally, a new supplementary HMA shear test, namely the simple punching shear test (SPST) was developed that showed good potential to be considered as a surrogate to the HWTT.
16
The Problem of Multiple Comparisons
John W. Tukey · Medical Entomology and Zoology · 1953 · 1.2K citations