MAST. Maritime studies/Maritime studies · 2015 · 76 citations · 50 references
Natural ResourcesEcologyFisheriesFisheries ConservationFisheries GovernanceFisheries ManagementAdaptive Fisheries GovernanceAdaptive Fisheries ManagementEcosystem-based Fisheries ManagementFisheries Co-managementSmall-scale Fisheries GovernanceSmall-scale Fisheries PolicyCollaborative Fisheries ManagementDesign PrinciplesFisheries Co-governanceFisheries Co-management NetworksFishery Resource Management
The literature on commons has established the validity and significance of Elinor Ostrom’s design principles for collective action. Can these principles be used to guide policies and initiatives towards adaptive co-management? We analyze this idea by using two case studies, Piriápolis (Uruguay) and Paraty (Brazil). Both cases are small-scale fisheries, and both have been experiencing a social-ecological crisis in a context of prevailing top-down government management. However, there are signs that government policies are moving towards participatory governance. The objective of this article is to identify opportunities and barriers to adaptive co-management of small-scale fisheries in Uruguay and Brazil using Ostrom’s design principles for guidance. Both case studies partially meet seven of the eleven design principles (as amended by Cox and colleagues), but do not fulfill four. The analysis of the fisheries using Ostrom’s principles sheds light on the opportunities and barriers to adaptive co-management in three categories: resource system, resource users, and governance system. Barriers include long-standing conflicts between small-scale fishers and government agencies, and between small and large-scale fisheries sectors. Nevertheless, recent initiatives involving participatory approaches to research and management show potential to improve compliance with several principles. Two weaknesses of using Ostrom’s principles for the analysis of the cases were a lack of attention to social learning and the exclusion of external drivers.
50
Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action
Barry C. Field · Land Economics · 1992 · 19.2K citations · Full text
The Struggle to Govern the Commons
Thomas Dietz, Paul C. Stern · Science · 2003 · 4.1K citations
Social Sciences, Environmental Management, Natural Resource Governance +15