From Dia- to Paramagnetic Orbital Susceptibility of Massless Fermions

Abstract

We study the orbital susceptibility of multiband systems with a pair of Dirac points interpolating between honeycomb and dice lattices. Despite having the same zero-field energy spectrum, these different systems exhibit spectacular differences in their orbital magnetic response, ranging from dia- to paramagnetism at Dirac points. We show that this striking behavior is related to a topological Berry phase varying continuously from π (graphene) to 0 (dice). The latter strongly constrains interband effects, resulting in an unusual dependence of the magnetic response also at finite doping.