Hydraulic characterization of aquifers by thermal response testing: Validation by large-scale tank and field experiments

Valentin Wagner, Peter Bayer, Gerhard Bisch, Markus Kübert, Philipp Blum

Water Resources Research · 2013 · 41 citations · 47 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Thermal response tests (TRTs) are a common field method in shallow geothermics that estimate the thermal properties of the ground and borehole heat exchanger by observing the temperature development of a constantly heated fluid. The authors evaluate TRTs by circulating heated fluid in closed tubes of a vertical borehole heat exchanger, applying a moving line source model that accounts for natural variability, and validate the approach with a large‑scale tank experiment and a 100‑m deep field test in a gravel aquifer. The study demonstrates that advection‑influenced TRTs can characterize aquifer hydraulic conductivity, yielding ranges comparable to pumping tests and sieve analyses, and thus can be used to determine integral hydraulic conductivity.

Abstract

[1] Thermal response tests (TRTs) are a common field method in shallow geothermics to estimate thermal properties of the ground. During the test, a constantly heated fluid is circulated in closed tubes within a vertical borehole heat exchanger (BHE). The observed temperature development of the fluid is characteristic for the thermal properties of the ground and the BHE. We show that, when the BHE is installed in an aquifer with significant horizontal groundwater flow, this test can also be used for hydrogeological characterization of the penetrated subsurface. An evaluation method based on the moving line source equation and considering the natural occurring variability of the thermal transport parameters is presented. It is validated by application to a well-controlled, large-scale tank experiment with 9 m length, 6 m width, and 4.5 m depth, and by data interpretation from a field-scale test. The tank experiment imitates an advection-influenced TRT in a well-known layered aquifer. The field experiment was recorded with a 100 m deep BHE, installed in a gravel aquifer in southwest Germany. The evaluations of both experiments result in similar hydraulic conductivity ranges as determined by standard hydraulic investigation methods such as pumping tests and sieve analyses. Thus, advection-influenced TRTs could also potentially be used to determine integral hydraulic conductivity of the subsurface.

References

47