A Comparison of Upper Ontologies.

Viviana Mascardi, Valentina Cordì, Paolo Rosso

2007 · 131 citations · 9 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Upper Ontologies are emerging as a key technology for integrating heterogeneous knowledge from diverse sources, serving as a lingua franca for intelligent agents that cannot disclose their full ontologies. This study aims to preliminarily explore Upper Ontologies as bridges for automatically aligning heterogeneous ontologies by reviewing the current state of the art. The authors evaluate seven Upper Ontologies—BFO, Cyc, DOLCE, GFO, PROTON, Sowa’s ontology, and SUMO—using standard software engineering criteria and present the results in a comparative table.

Abstract

Upper Ontologies are quickly becoming a key technology for integrating heterogeneous knowledge coming from different sources. In fact, they may be exploited as a “lingua franca” by intelligent software agents in all those scenarios where it is impossible (or there is no will) for an agent to disclose its own entire ontology to other agent, despite the need to communicate with it. This paper represents the very preliminary step towards the exploitation of Upper Ontologies as bridges for allowing intelligent software agents to align heterogeneous ontologies in an automatic way, where we analyse the most up-to-date state-of-theart. In this paper we analyse 7 Upper Ontologies, namely BFO, Cyc, DOLCE, GFO, PROTON, Sowa’s ontology, and SUMO, according to a set of standard software engineering criteria, and we synthesise our analysis in form of a comparative table. A summary of some existing comparisons drawn among subsets of the 7 Upper Ontologies that we deal with in this document, is also provided.

References

9