Thought A Journal of Philosophy · 2013 · 11 citations · 5 references
Language StudiesPhilosophyKnowledge RepresentationPhilosophy Of LanguageSemanticsCognitive SemanticsCompositional SemanticsCompositionalityMeaning RepresentationCompositionality PrinciplesPropositional RepresentationRepresentational Systems
In this article, we evaluate the Compositionality Argument for structured propositions. This argument hinges on two seemingly innocuous and widely accepted premises: the Principle of Semantic Compositionality and Propositionalism (the thesis that sentential semantic values are propositions). We show that the Compositionality Argument presupposes that compositionality involves a form of building, and that this metaphysically robust account of compositionality is subject to counter-example: there are compositional representational systems that this principle cannot accommodate. If this is correct, one of the most important arguments for structured propositions is undermined.
5
The Principle of Semantic Compositionality
Francis Jeffry Pelletier · Topoi · 1994 · 228 citations
On the Systematicity of Language and Thought
Kent Johnson · The Journal of Philosophy · 2004 · 125 citations
Compositionality As Supervenience
Zoltán Szabó · Linguistics and Philosophy · 2000 · 72 citations
Trenton Merricks · Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society · 2009 · 22 citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Self +8