The Experiences of an African American Male Learning Mathematics in the Traditional and Online Classroom--A Case Study.

Darryl Corey, Beverly L. Bower

The Journal of Negro Education · 2005 · 22 citations · 11 references

Concepts

Abstract

purpose of this study was to compare the learning experience of an African American male mathematics student within an online learning environment and in a traditional mathematics classroom. This case study examined the experiences of one African American male whose mathematics performance had historically been below average. Data collection methods included interviews, observations, and student artifacts. study examined the presence of cultural exchange within the traditional classroom and the online learning environment, and how these environments impacted this student's learning in algebra I. Findings supported the online environment over the traditional classroom. online classroom provided this student with access to information that facilitated his understanding of algebra at a pace and in an environment more supportive of his learning style. All names for individuals and institutions involved in this study are pseudonyms. INTRODUCTION Reports in the literature on student achievement indicate that African American students, particularly African American males, have historically performed lower academically than their White counterparts (National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2000, 2003; National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), 2003). No where is this phenomenon more prevalent than in the discipline of mathematics (NAEP, 2003). For a number of years, researchers have conducted studies that focus on the status of African American male students in mathematics (Snipes, 1997). Oakes (1986) reported that African American male students have historically found the mathematics classroom to be a difficult atmosphere in which to succeed. For example, the NAEP (2003) reported the gap in mathematics test scores for Sth-grade African American males and their White counterparts as ranging from 41 points in 1996 to 35 points in 2003. While this gap in test scores has been narrowing, African American males continue to produce lower than average results (NAEP, 2003). A popular explanation given by some researchers for this low mathematics performance by African American males is based on the contrast in cultural norms and beliefs between Black male students and their mostly Caucasian female teachers (Porter, 1997; Stiff & Harvey, 1988). The mathematics classroom functions under a set of values, orientations, and expectations that are unlikely to be the same as those in the African American culture (Snipes, 1997, p. 15). Many teachers are not aware of these cultural differences and, therefore, do not take them into consideration in the mathematics classroom. Concurrently, discussions in the distance-learning literature refer to the social and cultural divides that take place between the teacher and student within a web-based environment (see Hiltz, 1986; Peters, 1993; Vrasidas, 1999). Distance learning via computer delivery is expanding at extremely rapid rates. Technology such as the Internet, e-mail, and a variety of conferencing systems (e.g., web board, chat rooms) are now widely used for educational purposes. However, these courses can sometimes seem less personal since the nuances of socio-emotional exchange are expunged (Hiltz, 1986). Peters (1993) further states that distance education reduces education to an industrial production process that lacks the human dimension of group interaction and alienates the learner from teacher. These parallel discussions lead one to ask, Does distance learning via the Web present a possible solution to the cultural disconnect in mathematics instruction? These two environments serve as appropriate mechanisms for studying the effect of cultural differences between African American male students and their Caucasian female teachers on how these students learn mathematics. PURPOSE OF THE STUDY purpose of this study was to examine if learning mathematics at a distance, within a Web-supported environment, provided a more effective learning atmosphere than the traditional classroom for an African American male student. …

References

11