Insuring against Terrorism -- and Crime

Saul Levmore, Kyle D. Logue

Michigan Law Review · 2003 · 167 citations · 134 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The September 11 attacks caused massive loss of life and property, triggered large private insurance payouts and federal relief, and raised questions about the availability of terrorism insurance and the government’s role in subsidizing or ensuring such coverage. The authors argue that the specific mix of government responses to 9/11—including the Victims’ Compensation Fund and the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act—will shape private expectations about future government action, thereby influencing insurance policy design, real estate development, and charitable giving. The analysis indicates that the causal relationship could also run in the opposite direction.

Abstract

The attacks of September 11th produced staggering losses of life and property. They also brought forth substantial private-insurance payouts, as well as federal relief for the City of New York and for the families of individuals who perished on that day. The losses suffered during and after the attacks, and the structure of the relief effort, have raised questions about the availability of insurance against terrorism, the role of government in providing for, subsidizing, or ensuring the presence of such insurance, as well as the interaction between relief and the incentives for taking precautions against similar losses in the future. In response to such losses, and in anticipation of others, one might imagine an array of government responses ranging from nonintervention, to subsidized private insurance, to after-the-fact government payments of a fixed or uncertain kind. It is our claim that the particular mix of responses the government has chosen with respect to 9/11, including the September 11th Victims' Compensation Fund1 and the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act of 2002,2 will significantly affect private expectations about the government's likely response to future terrorist attacks. These expectations will in turn affect future private actions, ranging from the types of insurance policies that will be written, to the character of real estate development that will take place (especially in the country's largest cities), and to the level of charitable contributions that will be made following any future terrorist attack. The causal arrow can also point

References

134