Effects of acid etch parameters on enamel topography and composite resin--enamel bond strength.

DJ Bates, Retief Dh, Jamison Hc, Denys Fr

PubMed · 1982 · 31 citations · 13 references

Concepts

Abstract

The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of methods of acid application, wash times, and saliva contamination on the tensile bond strength of a composite resin to enamel Ninety human maxillary central incisors were used and the tensile bond strength was determined for the composite resin to enamel surfaces subjected to the following acid etch parameters. In the control group (A) the acid was applied by dabbing followed by a 30-secand wash. The acid was similarly applied for 30 seconds (B) and 120 seconds (C), rubbed for 60 seconds (D), not agitated 60 seconds (E) followed by 30 seconds wash respectively. Wash times of 5 seconds (F) and seconds (G) were used after 60 seconds of acid application by dabbing. Control procedures were followed by 30 seconds of saliva contamination and 5 seconds wash (H) or 5 seconds wash, 10 seconds re-etch and 30 seconds wash (I) were finally used. Incisors treated with one o.f each of the procedures were viewed in the SEM. Method of acid application by dabbing, rubbing, or no agil:ation resulted in bond strengths that were not significantly different, a 5-second wash after acid etching was sufficient to maintain bond strength and saliva contamination was eliminated by a 5-second wash. The effect of acid etch parameters on enamel topography was difficult to evaluate because of variable etch patterns. The acid etch procedure is essential for the establishment of the mechanical bond between composite dental resins and enamel. 1 It consists of several steps which may affect the bond strength of the composite resin to etched enamel. The first step of the acid etch technique involves the application of the orthophosphoric acid (H3PO4) etching solution to the enamel surface. Rubbing the enamel during conditioning adversely affects the bonding of composite resins to these surfaces. 2 Hormati and coworkers 3 reported, however, that the shear bond strength of a composite resin to enamel surfaces which were etched by a dabbing or a rubbing action were not significantly different despite the marked differences in etch patterns as observed by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The duration of etch and subsequent wash times are also important factors which may affect the bond strength of composite resins to etched enamel. It has been reported that with a short etch time of 10 seconds, the bond strengths increased as the wash time increased? Other studies showed that the bond strengths of a composite resin to enamel surfaces etched with 50% H3PO4 for five seconds or 60 seconds were not significantly different if the enamel was washed with at least two ml of water after etching? .~ Washing with quantities of water greater than this volume provided no additional benefit. On the other hand, it was reported that the tensile bond strength increased with a thorough 60-second wash time as opposed to a 15-second washy Bond strength may also be adversely affected by saliva contamination of the etched enamel surface. Hormati and coworkers3 reported that etched enamel surfaces which were air dried after a 60-second saliva contamination significantly reduced the shear bond strength of a composite resin when compared with bond strengths obtained on enamel surfaces which were re-etched, rewashed, and redried after similar saliva contamination. The objective of this investigation was to study further several of the parameters which may influence the bond strength of composite resins to etched enamel. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to determine the effects of the various procedures on the etching pattern of enamel. Methods and Materials Ninety noncarious, extracted human maxillary central incisors were used to study the tensile bond strength of a composite resin to etched enamel surfaces. The test method developed by Kemper and Kilian s was used in this investigation. Subsurface 106 EFFECTS OF ACID ETCH PARAMETERS: Bates, et al. Group Etch Application Wash Contamination Wash Re-etch Rewash (sec) Method (sec) Saliva {sec) (sec) (sec) (sec) Table 1. Acid etch procedures. A 60 dabbing B 30 dabbing C 120 dabbing D 60 rubbing E 60 no agitation F 60 dabbing G 60 dabbing H 60 dabbing I 60 dabbing 30 .... 30 .... 30 .... 30 30 30 5 --30 3O 5 10 3O enamel was exposed by lapping the facial surfaces of the crowns of the teeth on 600 grit silicon carbide paper in a polishing machinea under a continuous stream of water. The crowns were embedded in epoxy resin in the tooth specimen cups with the flat surfaces parallel to and projecting just above the lip of the cup. The epoxy resin was allowed to cure at room temperature for 24 hours and the embedded specimens were then stored in water at 37°C for at least 24 hours. Immediately prior to the preparation of the bonded test specimens the crown surfaces were lightly polished by placing the tooth cup in a polishing block on 600 grit silcon carbide paper in the polishing machine. This provided a planar enamel surface perpendicular to the direction of force application during the bond strength testing procedure. The embedded teeth were subjected to one of the procedures outlined in Table 1. A random distribution table was computer processed to determine the order in which the test specimens were to be prepared. The tooth surfaces were acid etched with 37% H3PO4, washed and dried with an air-water syringe. Water was collected in a graduated cylinder to determine the volume used in each washing procedure. Each timed collection was repeated 10 times and the average volume of water determined. A two paste composite resinb was mixed as directed, placed in the composite cup and assembled in the bonding alignment block. A low viscosity bonding resin was not applied to the etched enamel surfaces. The composite cup was lowered to contact the flat enamel surface. The composite resin was allowed to cure against the enamel surface under a load of one pound for 15 minutes at room temperature, after which the bonded specimens were carefully removed and stored in water at 37°C for 24 hours. Test specimens were mounted in the measurement alignment block and suspended in the jaws of an Instron c testing machine. The tensile load was applied at a rate of 0.02 aBuehler Ltd., 2120 Greenwood St., Evanston, I L. bConcise, 3 M Co., St. Paul, MN. inch/min until the bonded specimens failed. Tensile bond strengths were calculated and expressed in MN.m. -~ Statistical comparisons of the data were made by an analysis of variance at the 0.05 level of significance. Etch patterns for each treatment group were determined by subjecting two maxillary central incisor crowns to one of the procedures listed in Table 1. The etched crowns were coated with gold/palladium in a high vacuum evaporator d and examined in a Cambridge Mark 2Ae scanning electron microscope operated at 20 kV.

References

13