A hidden crisis: strengthening the evidence base on the sustainability of rural groundwater supplies: results from a pilot study in Uganda

H.C. Bonsor, Naomi Oates, P.J. Chilton, R.C. Carter, Vincent Casey, Alan MacDonald, Roger Calow, Rebecca Alowo, Paul Wilson, Martin Dahlin Tumutungire,

NERC Open Research Archive (Natural Environment Research Council) · 2015 · 16 citations · 0 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Extending and sustaining access to rural water supplies remains central to improving the health and
\nlivelihoods of poor people, particularly women, in Africa, where 400 million rural inhabitants have no
\nform of utility provided water, and universal access to water hinges on accelerated development of
\ngroundwater (UN 2013). The ‘future proofing’ of groundwater investments is therefore vital,
\nespecially in the context of global and local trends including demographic shifts, environmental
\nimpacts of human activity and climate change (Taylor et al. 2013).
\nThe emphasis, in recent years, on accelerating access to new infrastructure has obscured a hidden
\ncrisis of failure. More than 30% of sources are non‐functional within a few years of construction
\n(Rietveld et al. 2009, RWSN 2009, Lockwood et al. 2011) and a greater number are seasonal (for
\nexample 50% in Sierra Leone) (MoEWR 2012). The accumulated costs to governments, donors, and,
\nabove all, rural people, are enormous. The original benefits generated by the new infrastructure –
\nimproved health, nutrition, time savings, education, particularly for the poorest – are lost if
\nimproved services cannot be sustained. The cumulative effect of rural water supply failure in Africa
\nover the past 20 years has been estimated by the World Bank to represent a lost investment in
\nexcess of $1.2 billion.
\nCritically, there is limited data or analysis on why sources are non‐functional and therefore little
\nopportunity to learn from past mistakes.
\nThis report provides a summary of the work undertaken by the UK‐funded UPGro research
\nprogramme ('Unlocking the Potential for Groundwater for the Poor') for sub‐Saharan Africa (SSA)
\nfunded by the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC), the Economic and Social Research
\nCouncil (ESRC) and the Department for International Development (DfID). The Catalyst Grant project
\n‘A Hidden Crisis’ was aimed at developing a methodology and toolbox to investigate the causes of
\nfailure in groundwater‐based water services in SSA, which could form the foundation for more
\nsubstantial and larger‐scale research in the future to develop a statistically significant evidence base
\nto examine water point functionality and the underlying causes of failure across a range of physical,
\nsocial, institutional and governance environments in SSA. To test the toolbox and methodology
\ndeveloped, a pilot study was conducted in northeast Uganda
\nOverall, the approach and methods developed in the catalyst project have been shown to make a
\nsignificant step towards developing a replicable and robust methodology which can be used to
\ngenerate a systematic evidence base for supply failure. The work has gone a significant way to
\nencapsulating the complexity of the interlinked aspects of the problem, balancing the natural science
\nand engineering (“technical”) aspects of the research with those concerning the ability of
\ncommunities to manage and maintain their water points (the “social” aspects). The multiplicity of
\ninterlinked causes of water point failure was explicitly acknowledged and taken into account through
\nthe use of multi‐disciplinary field and analytical methods within the toolbox and in selection of the
\nresearch team. The multi‐disciplinary methods of investigation used were highly practical and
\nappropriate to the information sought, and based on detailed observational science.