THE ANTITRUST TYING LAW SCHISM: A CRITIQUE OF: MICROSOFT III: AND A RESPONSE TO HYLTON AND SALINGER

Warren S. Grimes

2016 · 21 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

There is a schism in antitrust tying law. The point of contention is the relevance of information asymmetries to a tie-in analysis. The court of appeals' en bane decision in United States v. Microsoft Corp. (Micosofl III)1 did not address the schism, yet that decision has charted a course that may describe tying law's future path out of the abyss. The Hylton and Salinger recent article on tying law and policy2 suggests a different path. The authors are critical of some aspects of Microsoft III, would largely ignore information issues that could demonstrate anticompetitive effect, and urge a virtual per se legality for high-technology, productintegration tie-ins. In these comments, I offer a critique of the tying law aspects of Microsoft ///and of the Hylton and Salinger article. I explain why Microsoft III is largely true to empiricism and mainstream antitrust' s recognition that information asymmetries can be, and often are, pivotal to accurate competitive analysis of a tie-in.